Abstract:Construction workplace hazard detection requires engineers to analyze scenes manually against many safety rules, which is time-consuming, labor-intensive, and error-prone. Computer vision algorithms are yet to achieve reliable discrimination of anomalous and benign object relations underpinning safety violation detections. Recently developed deep learning-based computer vision algorithms need tens of thousands of images, including labels of the safety rules violated, in order to train deep-learning networks for acquiring spatiotemporal reasoning capacity in complex workplaces. Such training processes need human experts to label images and indicate whether the relationship between the worker, resource, and equipment in the scenes violate spatiotemporal arrangement rules for safe and productive operations. False alarms in those manual labels (labeling no-violation images as having violations) can significantly mislead the machine learning process and result in computer vision models that produce inaccurate hazard detections. Compared with false alarms, another type of mislabels, false negatives (labeling images having violations as "no violations"), seem to have fewer impacts on the reliability of the trained computer vision models. This paper examines a new crowdsourcing approach that achieves above 95% accuracy in labeling images of complex construction scenes having safety-rule violations, with a focus on minimizing false alarms while keeping acceptable rates of false negatives. The development and testing of this new crowdsourcing approach examine two fundamental questions: (1) How to characterize the impacts of a short safety-rule training process on the labeling accuracy of non-professional image annotators? And (2) How to properly aggregate the image labels contributed by ordinary people to filter out false alarms while keeping an acceptable false negative rate? In designing short training sessions for online image annotators, the research team split a large number of safety rules into smaller sets of six. An online image annotator learns six safety rules randomly assigned to him or her, and then labels workplace images as "no violation" or 'violation" of certain rules among the six learned by him or her. About one hundred and twenty anonymous image annotators participated in the data collection. Finally, a Bayesian-network-based crowd consensus model aggregated these labels from annotators to obtain safety-rule violation labeling results. Experiment results show that the proposed model can achieve close to 0% false alarm rates while keeping the false negative rate below 10%. Such image labeling performance outdoes existing crowdsourcing approaches that use majority votes for aggregating crowdsourced labels. Given these findings, the presented crowdsourcing approach sheds lights on effective construction safety surveillance by integrating human risk recognition capabilities into advanced computer vision.

Recognition of High-Risk Scenarios in Building Construction Based on Image Semantics

Ontology-Based Semantic Modeling of Knowledge in Construction: Classification and Identification of Hazards Implied in Images

Onsite Video Mining for Construction Hazards Identification with Visual Relationships

Improved Vision-Based Method for Detection of Unauthorized Intrusion by Construction Sites Workers

Unsafe behavior identification on construction sites by combining computer vision and knowledge graph–based reasoning

Vision-based method for semantic information extraction in construction by integrating deep learning object detection and image captioning

Automatic construction site hazard identification integrating construction scene graphs with BERT based domain knowledge

Imagery Based Risk Assessment Using Crowdsourcing Technology in Complex Workspaces

Crowdsourced Reliable Labeling of Safety-Rule Violations on Images of Complex Construction Scenes for Advanced Vision-Based Workplace Safety

Computer vision and long short-term memory: Learning to predict unsafe behaviour in construction

Human Intrusion Detection in Static Hazardous Areas at Construction Sites: Deep Learning–Based Method

Intelligent Identification of Violation of Rules in Construction Site Based on Artificial Intelligence Image Recognition Technology

A Computer Vision-Based Approach to Classifying and Storing Image Data for Construction Safety Management

Skeleton-based Automatic Assessment and Prediction of Intrusion Risk in Construction Hazardous Areas

Construction site safety monitoring and excavator activity analysis system

Construction Site Safety Management: A Computer Vision and Deep Learning Approach

Real-Time Early Safety Warning for Personnel Intrusion Behavior on Construction Sites Using a CNN Model

Applications of Computer Vision in Monitoring the Unsafe Behavior of Construction Workers: Current Status and Challenges

Intelligent identification of risks in construction contract clauses based on semantic reasoning

Intelligent Mining of Safety Hazard Information from Construction Documents Using Semantic Similarity and Information Entropy

Real-time smart video surveillance to manage safety: A case study of a transport mega-project