Ultrahigh-Pressure Metamorphism in Eclogites from the Western Tianshan, China - Reply

Lf Zhang,D Ellis,S Williams,Wb Jiang
IF: 3.066
2003-01-01
American Mineralogist
Abstract:We thank Dr. Klemd for his comments on our recent papers about ultrahigh-pressure metamorphism in Western Tianshan, China (Zhang et al. 2002a, 2002b). It is good to have this opportunity to respond to his comments and to clarify some of our statements in detail. First of all, we wish to point out that we have never concluded that “all rocks from Chinese western Tianshan have undergone ultrahigh-pressure metamorphism” as claimed by Dr. Klemd, but rather “some eclogites of studied samples have undergone ultrahigh-pressure metamorphism (UHPM)”. It should be noted that samples we studied were collected from different outcrops and localities from those considered by Klemd and Gao, although we worked in the same area of Western Tianshan, China. His comments are mainly related to three aspects of mineralogic evidence for UHP in the eclogites from Western Tianshan (Zhang et al. 2002a, 2002b): (1) coesite pseudomorphs as inclusions in garnet; (2) quartz exsolution lamellae in omphacite; and (3) metamorphic magnesite in eclogite. Our responses are as follows. The characteristics of quartz pseudomorphs after coesite as inclusions in garnet with radial fractures in eclogites from Western Tianshan are quite different from those described by Wendt et al. (1993) in metapelites from the southeastern Saih Hatat tectonic window, Northeastern Oman Mountains. In contrast to the Oman metapelites, there are no apatite inclusions surrounded by radial cracks in garnet, and no separation between core and rim of the garnet after radial cracking in the Tianshan eclogites. The most important difference between the Oman and Tianshan eclogites is that, in the latter, the quartz inclusions surrounded by radial cracks are fine-grained polycrystalline aggregates of quartz with a “palisade” texture, i.e., the fine quartz grains are elongated perpendicular to the center in Tianshan eclogites (Figs. 3c and 3d in Zhang et al. 2002a), whereas …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?