From vocational to graduation: A mixed methods study of support needs for vocational learners pursuing post-graduate education in South Africa

Debbi Groome,Charmaine Cunningham

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.afjem.2024.08.008

IF: 1.451

2024-09-14

African Journal of Emergency Medicine

Abstract:Highlights • Vocational learning has been the cornerstone of Africa's educational heritage, providing essential skills within communities. • Recognition of Prior Learning aims to connect informal learning histories with formal academic qualifications, a critical step in correcting historical educational imbalances across Africa. • The current Recognition of Prior Learning framework in South Africa fails to effectively address vocational learners' unique needs and challenges entering postgraduate education. Introduction Vocational learning has been critical in shaping South Africa's workforce, especially for paramedicine. The introduction of the National Qualification Framework (NQF) in 1995 phased out previous short course learning systems and redesigned qualifications within the framework. While recognition of prior learning is well advocated in the NQF, the predominant focus is undergraduate studies. The leap from vocational to Higher Education can be significant, especially for non-seasoned learners, and additional support may be required to ensure a successful transition. This study describes the support needs of vocational paramedics transitioning to post-graduate education. Methods The study used a two-phase sequential design to achieve the aims. The first phase was conducted in 2021 and involved an analysis of grades followed by semi-structured interviews to obtain qualitative insights. The second phase, conducted in 2022, focused exclusively on collecting quantitative data to validate and expand upon the initial findings from phase one. Results Analysis of the academic results over two years between Recognition of Prior Learning (RPL) and non-RPL candidates showed a difference of 4 % in the aggregated mark. This indicates that the RPL candidates have the academic acumen to succeed in a post-graduate diploma education program. Interview analysis revealed the support requirements were not academic but rather technological and institutional, with navigation of the university's learning management system being a common challenge. Hesitancy to access formal support services was noted as a university barrier. Conclusion This study highlights the academic ability of students from vocational backgrounds to succeed in post-graduate programs. These learners demonstrated strong academic performance despite entering higher education through a non-traditional pathway. Whilst advocating for consideration and refinement of the role of RPL within the NQF, this research suggests a re-evaluation of current support systems for vocational learners transitioning to post-graduate studies.

emergency medicine