Proper Tools and Technique Improve Biliary Papillotomy: A Simulation Study

Joseph Leung,Wei-Chih David Liao,Wenbo Meng,Andrew Yen,Dong Wang,Yanglin Pan,Hp Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14309/00000434-201410002-01942

2014-01-01

Abstract:Introduction: Outcome of biliary papillotomy depends on alignment of papillotome with “perfect” biliary axis (BA). Orientation of BA can change with distorted anatomy. A deviated papillotome cutting wire alters the alignment and affects the cut. Pre-shaping a papillotome can improve wire alignment. We tested the hypothesis that pre-shaping a papillotome can improve the papillotomy using the EMS. Methods: Seventeen GI trainees attended talks on perfect BA, scope/papillotome alignment and control of cutting. They performed artificial papillotomy using EMS. Nine were randomly assigned marked papillae with “perfect” BA, 8 were given blank papillae. Using papillotomes(DASH 025, Cook), trainees performed papillotomies with 1.) regular (un-manipulated) papillotome where cutting wire generally deviates slightly to the right with traction, 2.) pre-shaped papillotome where cutting wire was positioned on left side, more aligned with perfect BA. Papillotomy was recorded, coded for review by blinded observer. Papillotomy performance was scored (based on position of cutting wire, direction of cut and control of cutting, with a 9 point scale; 9=excellent and 3=poor). Trainees responded to survey on practice credibility. Results: Data of 17 video recordings presented in Table 1. There were significantly higher scores and shorter procedure time for papillotomies performed with pre-shaped papillotome compared to regular papillotome. There were better scores for marked vs. blank papillae. There was a significant increase in post-practice credibility score (Table 2).Table 1: Comparison of Papillotomy Performance (Score)Table 2: Pre and Post-practice Survey on Credibility of EMS practiceConclusion: Trainees performed significantly better artificial papillotomies using a pre-shaped papillotome due to better axis alignment and less adjustment for the cut, compared to regular papillotome. A proper tool ensures good alignment which may improve outcome of papillotomy. Disclosure - J Leung received research equipment support from Cook Endoscopy and Olympus, research grant support from Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, UC Davis Medical Center, and travel support from Chinese Society of Digestive Endoscopy to conduct this study. The other co-authors have no relevant financial relationship to disclose.