Abstract:The sucrose preference test is a popular test for anhedonia in the chronic unpredictable stress model of depression. Yet, the test does not always produce consistent results. Long food and water deprivation before the test, while often implemented, confounds the results by introducing unwanted drives in the form of hunger and thirst. We assessed the reliability of the test when only short or no fasting was used. We searched PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science for studies in rats exposed to chronic unpredictable stress that used no more than 6 h of food and/or water deprivation before the test. Sweet consumptions, for stressed and control/antidepressant-treated animals, in 132 studies were pooled using random effects models. We found a decrease in sweet consumption in stressed rats, compared to controls, that was halved when a non-caloric sweetener was used and significantly reduced when sucrose consumption was corrected for body weight. What is more, the length of food and water deprivation was found to confound the effect. The effect was reversed when the stressed rats were treated with antidepressants. Methodological strategies meant to control for recognized sources of bias when conducting the test were often missing, and so was a clear and complete report of essential study information. Our results indicate that not only is food and water deprivation before the test unnecessary, but not recommended. Even in absence of long fasting, we found evidence of an additional effect on sweet consumption that is unrelated to anhedonia. Without properly controlling for non-hedonic drivers of consumption, the test is unreliable as a proxy measure of anhedonia. Strengthening the methodological rigor and addressing the confounding effect of metabolic factors in the sucrose preference test prevents misleading conclusions that harm the translatability of the associated research and perpetuates the use of animals for little gain.

Sucrose Preference Test to Measure Anhedonic Behaviour in Mice

Sucrose preference test for measurement of stress-induced anhedonia in mice

A novel method for automatic pharmacological evaluation of sucrose preference change in depression mice

Sucrose Preference Test as a Measure of Anhedonic Behavior in a Chronic Unpredictable Mild Stress Model of Depression: Outstanding Issues

Reliability of sucrose preference testing following short or no food and water deprivation—a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of rat models of chronic unpredictable stress

Anhedonic-like traits and lack of affective deficits in 18-month-old C57BL/6 mice: Implications for modeling elderly depression

Alteration of sweet taste receptor expression in circumvallate papillae of mice with decreased sweet taste preference induced by social defeat stress

Influence of experimental context on the development of anhedonia in male mice imposed to chronic social stress

Optimization of food deprivation and sucrose preference test in SD rat model undergoing chronic unpredictable mild stress

Antidepressant-Like Effects of Sanyuansan in the Mouse Forced Swim Test, Tail Suspension Test, and Chronic Mild Stress Model

Dietary protein restriction diminishes sucrose reward and reduces sucrose-evoked mesolimbic dopamine signaling in mice

Dietary protein restriction diminishes sucrose reward and reduces sucrose-evoked mesolimbic dopamine signaling

Altered reward processing following sucrose bingeing in male and female mice

Validity of chronic restraint stress for modeling anhedonic-like behavior in rodents: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Impact of excessive sucrose intake on mouse behavior across different developmental stages

Effects of chronic unpredictable mild stress-induced depression on bitter taste receptor expression in mice

Anhedonia and activity deficits in rats: impact of post-stroke depression

Sucrose Preference is Restored by Electro-Acupuncture Combined with Chlorimipramine in the Depression-Model Rats

[Sucrose reward promotes rats' motivation for cocaine].

Subchronic and mild social defeat stress downregulates peripheral expression of sweet and umami taste receptors in male mice