Abstract:This exploratory study identified and compared the organization, services, challenges of and motivations for makerspaces in public, academic, and school libraries in China. Although there is a significant body of literature on makerspaces in libraries, this study is one of the first ones that provides a comparison of library makerspace organization and operation by library type. Data was collected using paper and online surveys from 158 librarians. Supporting learning was the most frequently identified motivation for establishing a makerspace by all three categories of librarians. While makerspaces in academic libraries were mostly operated by library staff, school libraries more evenly relied on teaching staff, volunteers, library staff members, and paid instructors to operate their makerspaces. Makerspaces in public and academic libraries were funded mostly from the libraries’ budget, while school libraries were funded more by other units on the campus and institutional or individual investments. The most frequently selected technologies were 3D printing and modeling technologies, and makerspaces in academic libraries were better equipped than makerspaces in the other two types of libraries. Group study rooms and learning commons centers were the most frequently occurring physical spaces in academic and public library makerspaces. School library makerspaces differentiated themselves by offering wooden crafts centers more often than other library makerspaces. While participants selecting budget limitation and inadequate equipment as barriers to implementing makerspaces was not surprising, public and academic librarians also often cited the lack of professional instructors. Based on the findings, several suggestions were offered to the practice of planning and operating a makerspace in libraries such as bringing together internal and external funding to support makerspaces, consolidating the required physical space of makerspaces and the existing space arrangement of libraries, and developing additional training programs to address the problem of a lack of professional instructors.

Research on the Policy Text of Maker Space in Zhejiang Province of China

CONNOTATION, DEVELOPMENT AND PLANNING STRATEGIES OF MAKER SPACE FOR INTERNET ENTREPRENEURS: RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS BASED ON SHANGHAI

Creating a Makerspace in a Characteristic Town: the Case of Dream Town in Hangzhou

Non-R&D Innovation Patterns in Chinese SMEs: an Empirical Study from Zhejiang Province

Analysis on the Effectiveness and Mechanisms of Public Policies to Promote Innovation of High-Tech Startups in Makerspaces

Open Innovation in Chinese High-Tech Enterprises: an Empirical Research Based on Zhejiang Province

Innovating Regulatory Planning with Examples of American Zoning Regulations

Study on the Development Path of the Maker Space Based on the Theory of Entrepreneurial Ecosystem

Makerspace Activities in China

Implication of makerspace layout design in rural primary schools of Lianyungang, Jiangsu Province, China

Innovation and Upgrading in Manufacturing:Investigation on the Maker Community in Shenzhen

Policy Zoning Method for Innovation Districts to Sustainably Develop the Knowledge-Economy: A Case Study in Hangzhou, China

Co-Design visions of public makerspaces in China

The Mechanism and Effect of the Internet on Regional Innovation in China

The Research on the Co-location Between Producer Services and Manufacturing the Empirical Analyses Based on the 69 Cities and Regions in Zhejiang Province

A Research on Spatial Autocorrelation of Innovation Output and Its Influencing Factors in Zhejiang Province

A Study On The Registration Of Urban Underground Space: Hangzhou As The Case Study

Library makerspaces in China: A comparison of public, academic, and school libraries

The Innovation and Development Path of Cultural and Creative Industries in Anhui Province, China: Nvivo12-Based Policy Text Analysis

The Impact of Local Government Policy on Innovation Ecosystem in Knowledge Resource Scarce Region: Case Study of Changzhou, China

The impact of policy-making on innovation performance in industrial clusters:An empirical research on Science Parks in china