Abstract:Short-amplicon 16S rRNA gene sequencing is currently the method of choice for studies investigating microbiomes. However, comparative studies on differences in procedures are scarce. We sequenced human stool samples and mock communities with increasing complexity using a variety of commonly used protocols. Short amplicons targeting different variable regions (V-regions) or ranges thereof (V1-V2, V1-V3, V3-V4, V4, V4-V5, V6-V8, and V7-V9) were investigated for differences in the composition outcome due to primer choices. Next, the influence of clustering (operational taxonomic units [OTUs], zero-radius OTUs [zOTUs], and amplicon sequence variants [ASVs]), different databases (GreenGenes, the Ribosomal Database Project, Silva, the genomic-based 16S rRNA Database, and The All-Species Living Tree), and bioinformatic settings on taxonomic assignment were also investigated. We present a systematic comparison across all typically used V-regions using well-established primers. While it is known that the primer choice has a significant influence on the resulting microbial composition, we show that microbial profiles generated using different primer pairs need independent validation of performance. Further, comparing data sets across V-regions using different databases might be misleading due to differences in nomenclature (e.g., Enterorhabdus versus Adlercreutzia ) and varying precisions in classification down to genus level. Overall, specific but important taxa are not picked up by certain primer pairs (e.g., Bacteroidetes is missed using primers 515F-944R) or due to the database used (e.g., Acetatifactor in GreenGenes and the genomic-based 16S rRNA Database). We found that appropriate truncation of amplicons is essential and different truncated-length combinations should be tested for each study. Finally, specific mock communities of sufficient and adequate complexity are highly recommended. IMPORTANCE In 16S rRNA gene sequencing, certain bacterial genera were found to be underrepresented or even missing in taxonomic profiles when using unsuitable primer combinations, outdated reference databases, or inadequate pipeline settings. Concerning the last, quality thresholds as well as bioinformatic settings (i.e., clustering approach, analysis pipeline, and specific adjustments such as truncation) are responsible for a number of observed differences between studies. Conclusions drawn by comparing one data set to another (e.g., between publications) appear to be problematic and require independent cross-validation using matching V-regions and uniform data processing. Therefore, we highlight the importance of a thought-out study design including sufficiently complex mock standards and appropriate V-region choice for the sample of interest. The use of processing pipelines and parameters must be tested beforehand.

An optimized 16S rRNA sequencing protocol for vaginal microbiome to avoid biased abundance estimation

Comparison of Real-Time Quantitative PCR and 16S Rdna Sequencing for Detection of Female Vaginal Microbiome

Species-level resolution for the vaginal microbiota with short amplicons

Molecular Analysis of the Diversity of Vaginal Microbiota Associated with Bacterial Vaginosis

Primer, Pipelines, Parameters: Issues in 16S rRNA Gene Sequencing

Illumina Sequencing 16S Rrna Tagging Reveals Diverse Vaginal Microbiomes Associated with Bacterial Vaginosis

In Silico and Experimental Evaluation of Primer Sets for Species-Level Resolution of the Vaginal Microbiota Using 16S Ribosomal RNA Gene Sequencing

Optimization of the 16S Rrna Sequencing Analysis Pipeline for Studying in Vitro Communities of Gut Commensals.

Characterization of vaginal microbiomes in clinician-collected bacterial vaginosis diagnosed samples

An accurate and efficient experimental approach for characterization of the complex oral microbiota

Development of a Multiplex Real-Time Quantitative PCR Assay for Detecting Vaginal Microbiota in Chinese Women - China, 2021-2022

Comparison of commercial DNA extraction kits for whole metagenome sequencing of human oral, vaginal, and rectal microbiome samples

16S rRNA gene sequencing of mock microbial populations- impact of DNA extraction method, primer choice and sequencing platform

A multi-amplicon 16S rRNA sequencing and analysis method for improved taxonomic profiling of bacterial communities

Impact of DNA extraction method and targeted 16S-rRNA hypervariable region on oral microbiota profiling

Highly accurate and sensitive absolute quantification of bacterial strains in human fecal samples

A New Illumina MiSeq High‐throughput Sequencing‐based Method for Evaluating the Composition of the Bacteroides Community in the Intestine Using the Rpsd Gene Sequence

Optimized bacterial absolute quantification method by qPCR using an exogenous bacterial culture as a normalization strategy in triple-species BV-like biofilms

Single-Molecule Approach to 16S rRNA for Vaginal Microbiome Signatures in Response to Metronidazole Treatment

The 16S rRNA lung microbiome in mechanically ventilated patients: a methodological study

The Impact of Primer Design on Amplicon-Based Metagenomic Profiling Accuracy: Detailed Insights into Bifidobacterial Community Structure