Detecting and Predicting Pilot Mental Workload Using Heart Rate Variability: A Systematic Review

Peizheng Wang,Robert Houghton,Arnab Majumdar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s24123723

IF: 3.9

2024-06-08

Sensors

Abstract:Measuring pilot mental workload (MWL) is crucial for enhancing aviation safety. However, MWL is a multi-dimensional construct that could be affected by multiple factors. Particularly, in the context of a more automated cockpit setting, the traditional methods of assessing pilot MWL may face challenges. Heart rate variability (HRV) has emerged as a potential tool for detecting pilot MWL during real-flight operations. This review aims to investigate the relationship between HRV and pilot MWL and to assess the performance of machine-learning-based MWL detection systems using HRV parameters. A total of 29 relevant papers were extracted from three databases for review based on rigorous eligibility criteria. We observed significant variability across the reviewed studies, including study designs and measurement methods, as well as machine-learning techniques. Inconsistent results were observed regarding the differences in HRV measures between pilots under varying levels of MWL. Furthermore, for studies that developed HRV-based MWL detection systems, we examined the diverse model settings and discovered that several advanced techniques could be used to address specific challenges. This review serves as a practical guide for researchers and practitioners who are interested in employing HRV indicators for evaluating MWL and wish to incorporate cutting-edge techniques into their MWL measurement approaches.

engineering, electrical & electronic,instruments & instrumentation,chemistry, analytical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to use heart rate variability (HRV) to detect and predict pilots' mental workload (MWL) in order to improve aviation safety**.

Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **The importance of mental workload (MWL)**:
- A high level of MWL may impair human performance and lead to fatal accidents. Conversely, an overly low MWL may lead to boredom and inattentiveness, which also endangers operational safety.
- The aviation industry is a complex sociotechnical system that requires processing information from multiple sources, including visual, auditory cues, and environmental inputs. Therefore, effectively managing pilots' MWL is crucial for ensuring safety and operational efficiency.

2. **Limitations of traditional methods**:
- In an automated cockpit environment, traditional methods for assessing pilots' MWL may face challenges. For example, subjective measurements rely on self - reports and may be biased; performance - based measurement methods are usually reactive and cannot foresee potential risks in advance.

3. **Heart rate variability (HRV) as a potential tool**:
- HRV, as a physiological signal, has been proven to reflect changes in the activity of the autonomic nervous system (ANS) and is closely related to MWL. HRV parameters can be measured through time - domain and frequency - domain analyses, and these indicators can show different changes at different MWL levels.
- Although previous studies have shown the effectiveness of HRV in detecting fatigue and drowsiness, in complex pilot operations, there is still no consistent conclusion regarding the response of HRV to different MWL levels.

4. **Application of machine learning**:
- Machine - learning algorithms have shown good performance in detecting different MWL levels based on HRV features, but currently, there is no systematic review specifically exploring the application of these techniques in predicting pilots' MWL.

To address the above problems, this paper aims to:
- Explore the relationship between HRV and pilots' MWL through a systematic review of existing literature.
- Evaluate the performance of machine - learning models that use HRV parameters for MWL detection.
- Provide a practical guide to help researchers and practitioners better use HRV indicators to assess MWL and incorporate advanced technologies into their MWL measurement methods.

Through these efforts, this study not only hopes to enhance our understanding of pilots' MWL measurement but also hopes to pave the way for the development of more efficient automated systems to monitor pilots' MWL fluctuations in real - time.