Abstract:To meet the global climate goals agreed upon regarding the Paris Agreement, governments and institutions around the world are investigating various technologies to reduce carbon emissions and achieve a net-negative energy system. To this end, integrated solutions that incorporate carbon utilization processes, as well as promote the transition of the fossil fuel-based energy system to carbon-free systems, such as the hydrogen economy, are required. One of the possible pathways is to utilize CO2 as the base chemical for producing a liquid organic hydrogen carrier (LOHC), using CO2 as a mediating chemical for delivering H2 to the site of usage since gaseous and liquid H2 retain transportation and storage problems. Formic acid is a probable candidate considering its high volumetric H2 capacity and low toxicity. While previous studies have shown that formic acid is less competitive as an LOHC candidate compared to other chemicals, such as methanol or toluene, the results were based on out-of-date process schemes. Recently, advances have been made in the formic acid production and dehydrogenation processes, and an analysis regarding the recent process configurations could deem formic acid as a feasible option for LOHC. In this study, the potential for using formic acid as an LOHC is evaluated, with respect to the state-of-the-art formic acid production schemes, including the use of heterogeneous catalysts during thermocatalytic and electrochemical formic acid production from CO2. Assuming a hydrogen distribution system using formic acid as the LOHC, each of the production, transportation, dehydrogenation, and CO2 recycle sections are separately modeled and evaluated by means of techno-economic analysis (TEA) and life cycle assessment (LCA). Realistic scenarios for hydrogen distribution are established considering the different transportation and CO2 recovery options; then, the separate scenarios are compared to the results of a liquefied hydrogen distribution scenario. TEA results showed that, while the LOHC system incorporating the thermocatalytic CO2 hydrogenation to formic acid is more expensive than liquefied H2 distribution, the electrochemical CO2 reduction to formic acid system reduces the H2 distribution cost by 12%. Breakdown of the cost compositions revealed that reduction of steam usage for thermocatalytic processes in the future can make the LOHC system based on thermocatalytic CO2 hydrogenation to formic acid to be competitive with liquefied H2 distribution if the production cost could be reduced by 23% and 32%, according to the dehydrogenation mode selected. Using formic acid as a LOHC was shown to be less competitive compared to liquefied H2 delivery in terms of LCA, but producing formic acid via electrochemical CO2 reduction was shown to retain the lowest global warming potential among the considered options.

A comparative study on carbon neutral hydrogen carrier production: Formic acid from CO 2 vs. ammonia

Recent Advances in Catalytic Transfer Hydrogenation with Formic Acid over Heterogeneous Transition Metal Catalysts

Recent Developments in Reversible CO2 Hydrogenation and Formic Acid Dehydrogenation over Molecular Catalysts

Recent progress of heterogeneous catalysts for transfer hydrogenation under the background of carbon neutrality

Recent Progress on Ammonia Cracking Technologies for Scalable Hydrogen Production

Catalyst Design and Engineering for CO2‐to‐Formic Acid Electrosynthesis for a Low‐Carbon Economy

Heterogeneous Catalytic Systems for Carbon Dioxide Hydrogenation to Value-Added Chemicals

Recent progress in electrochemical synthesis of carbon-free hydrogen carrier ammonia and ammonia fuel cells: A review

Recent progress on heterogeneous catalytic formic acid decomposition for hydrogen production

Formic Acid to Power towards Low‐Carbon Economy

Advancement in integrated ammonia synthesis, and its techno-economic analysis, emission index, and contribution to the hydrogen 2.0 economy

Review of CO2 Reduction on Supported Metals (Alloys) and Single-Atom Catalysts (SACs) for the Use of Green Hydrogen in Power-to-Gas Concepts

Research progress in green synthesis of ammonia as hydrogen-storage carrier under ‘hydrogen 2.0 economy’

Catalytic Cracking of Ammonia toward Carbon-Neutral Liquid Fuel

Recent Progress in Molecular Transition Metal Catalysts for Hydrogen Production from Methanol and Formaldehyde

Advancements in Thermocatalytic Ammonia Decomposition for Hydrogen Production

Research Status, Optimization Strategies, and Future Prospects of Ammonia Decomposition Catalysts for COx-Free Hydrogen

Implementation of Formic Acid as a Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carrier (LOHC): Techno-Economic Analysis and Life Cycle Assessment of Formic Acid Produced via CO2 Utilization

Highly Selective Hydrogenation of CO 2 into Formic Acid on a Nano-Ni Catalyst at Ambient Temperature: Process, Mechanisms and Catalyst Stability

Hydrogenation of CO2 into Value‐added Chemicals Using Solid‐Supported Catalysts

Enabling Heterogeneous Catalysis to Achieve Carbon Neutrality: Directional Catalytic Conversion of CO$_2$ into Carboxylic Acids