Investigating the Impact of Various Vegetation Scenarios on Outdoor Thermal Comfort in Low-Density Residential Areas of Hot Arid Regions

Mohammed M. Gomaa,Adel E. L. Menshawy,Jackline Nabil,Ayman Ragab
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16103995
IF: 3.9
2024-05-10
Sustainability
Abstract:In hot, arid regions, outdoor spaces suffer from intense heat. This study explores how vegetation can improve outdoor thermal performance for pedestrians in low-density residential areas. Specifically, it seeks to identify the best combination of grass and trees for optimal comfort. Four scenarios were simulated using ENVI-met software, varying the proportions of grass and three tree types: 50% grass, 50% grass with 25% trees, 50% grass with 50% trees, and 50% grass with 75% trees. A reference scenario with no vegetation was also investigated. The simulated outputs encompassed air temperature (Ta), mean radiant temperature (Tmrt), relative humidity (RH), and physiologically equivalent temperature (PET). The findings show that scenarios with a higher percentage of trees exhibited the best reduction in air temperature, ranging from 0.2 k to 0.92 k. Additionally, the inclusion of trees and grass in the scenarios resulted in a substantial improvement in thermal performance, with an average reduction of 7.5 degrees in PET. Among the evaluated scenarios, the one comprising 75% trees and 50% grass exhibits the most noteworthy enhancement. This study underscores the significance of strategically positioning vegetation to coincide with prevailing wind patterns, thereby enhancing convective cooling mechanisms and improving overall thermal comfort levels. These insights offer valuable implications for urban planning and the development of sustainable design strategies.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of outdoor thermal comfort in low-density residential areas in hot and arid regions. Specifically, the study aims to explore the impact of different vegetation scenarios (including various combinations of grass and trees) on pedestrian outdoor thermal comfort, in order to determine the optimal vegetation configuration to improve the outdoor thermal environment in these areas. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **Impact of different vegetation scenarios on outdoor thermal comfort**: By simulating different proportions of grass and tree combinations, evaluate their effects on parameters such as air temperature, mean radiant temperature, relative humidity, and physiological equivalent temperature (PET). 2. **Optimal vegetation configuration**: Identify the optimal combination ratio of grass and trees that can most effectively enhance outdoor thermal comfort in low-density residential areas in hot and arid regions. 3. **Relationship between vegetation and wind direction**: Explore how strategic vegetation layout, combined with the local prevailing wind direction, can enhance convective cooling mechanisms to further improve overall thermal comfort levels. ### Research Background: The temperature rise caused by global warming has significantly impacted both outdoor and indoor thermal comfort, especially in hot and arid regions. The urban heat island (UHI) effect causes urban areas to have significantly higher temperatures than surrounding rural areas, exacerbating thermal comfort issues. Therefore, studying how vegetation can mitigate this problem is of great importance for improving the quality of life and health of urban residents. ### Research Methods: - **Field Measurements**: Collect data on current microclimate conditions to validate the simulation model. - **ENVI-met Software Simulation**: Use ENVI-met 5.5.1 software to simulate current conditions and other proposed mitigation scenarios, including different proportions of grass and tree combinations. - **Simulation Parameters**: Include air temperature, relative humidity, wind speed, and solar radiation, to assess thermal comfort under different vegetation scenarios. ### Research Significance: - **Urban Planning**: Provide scientific evidence for urban planners and policymakers to guide them in the rational configuration of vegetation when designing low-density residential areas to improve outdoor thermal comfort. - **Sustainable Development**: Optimize vegetation layout to reduce the urban heat island effect and promote sustainable urban development. In summary, this paper aims to provide an effective strategy for improving outdoor thermal comfort in low-density residential areas in hot and arid regions through systematic research.