Evaluating the Effects of Non-Isomorphic Rotation on 3D Manipulation Tasks in Mixed Reality Simulation

Zihan Gao,Huiqiang Wang,Hongwu Lv,Moshu Wang,Yifan Qi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tvcg.2020.3010247
IF: 5.2
2020-01-01
IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics
Abstract:As a hyper-natural interaction technique in 3D user interfaces, non-isomorphic rotation has been considered an effective approach for rotation tasks, where a static or dynamic control-display gain can be applied to amplify or attenuate a rotation. However, it is not clear whether non-isomorphic rotation can benefit 6-degree-of-freedom (6-DOF) manipulation tasks in AR and VR. In this article, we extended the usability studies of non-isomorphic rotation from rotation-only tasks to 6-DOF manipulation tasks and analyzed the collected data using a 2-component model. Using a mixed reality (MR) simulation approach, we also investigated whether environment (AR or VR) had an impact on 3D manipulation tasks. The results reveal that although both static and dynamic non-isomorphic rotation techniques could save time and effort in ballistic phases, only dynamic non-isomorphic rotation was significantly faster than isomorphic rotation. Interestingly, while environment had no significant impact on overall user performance, we found evidence that it could affect fine-tuning in correction phases. We also found that most participants preferred AR over VR, indicating that environmental visual realism could be helpful to improve user experience.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?