The typology of school leaders and teachers' outcomes: a latent profile analysis of paternalistic leadership
Shenghua Huang,Hongbiao Yin,Xiaodan Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-024-05835-7
IF: 2.8
2024-03-20
Current Psychology
Abstract:Benevolence, morality, and authoritarianism are the three critical dimensions of paternalistic leadership rooted in Chinese cultures and may represent the relation-oriented, values-oriented, and task-oriented leadership styles under the western research framework. Using the person-centered latent profile analysis, this study investigated the profiles of paternalistic school leaders as perceived by teachers in order to determine whether these profiles in educational setting align with theories and evidence obtained from other settings. A total of 653 primary school teachers from Beijing and 731 primary school teachers from Jilin province participated in this study. The Beijing sample was used in initial profile identification, while the Jilin sample and the integrated sample were used in profile confirmation. The final results generally supported a 5-profile model, with the five profiles labelled as dictatorial paternalistic leaders, semi-ideological paternalistic leaders, semi-benefactor paternalistic leaders, selfless benefactor paternalistic leaders, and authentic paternalistic leaders, respectively. The automatic BCH approach was then used to estimate and compare the means of distal continuous outcomes across the five latent profiles. The results indicated that when teachers perceived leadership profiles as high in benevolence and morality, they also reported greater work engagement and teacher efficacy. When teachers perceived leadership profiles as high in authoritarianism, they also reported greater emotional exhaustion and turnover intention. Teachers under the leadership of authentic paternalistic leaders reported the highest levels of work engagement and teacher efficacy, as well as the highest levels of emotional exhaustion and turnover intention.
psychology, multidisciplinary