Effect of Use of a Bougie vs Endotracheal Tube With Stylet on Successful Intubation on the First Attempt Among Critically Ill Patients Undergoing Tracheal Intubation: A Randomized Clinical Trial
Brian E Driver,Matthew W Semler,Wesley H Self,Adit A Ginde,Stacy A Trent,Sheetal Gandotra,Lane M Smith,David B Page,Derek J Vonderhaar,Jason R West,Aaron M Joffe,Steven H Mitchell,Kevin C Doerschug,Christopher G Hughes,Kevin High,Janna S Landsperger,Karen E Jackson,Michelle P Howell,Sarah W Robison,John P Gaillard,Micah R Whitson,Christopher M Barnes,Andrew J Latimer,Vikas S Koppurapu,Bret D Alvis,Derek W Russell,Kevin W Gibbs,Li Wang,Christopher J Lindsell,David R Janz,Todd W Rice,Matthew E Prekker,Jonathan D Casey,BOUGIE Investigators and the Pragmatic Critical Care Research Group,Christopher S Gray,Andrea Fletcher,Sally Dye,Swati Gulati,Michael C Kurz,Carolynn Lyle,Stephanie Gravitz,Erika Lw Rice,Nathaniel D Westphal,Itay Bentov,Jamie Stang,Paige DeVries,Ellen Maruggi,Bradley Lloyd,Anthony T Defebio,Feysel Mohamed,Robert Mitchell,Justin N Oeth,Angela Otoo,Elizabeth A Farmer,Dvonne A Duran,Cori Withers,Jennifer Friedel,Karina M Nava,Anna Altz-Stamm,Cristina Bardita,Mary C Boone,Joe W Chiles 3rd,Kristina Collins,Abby Drescher,Kevin G Dsouza,Janna Dunn,Stacy Ejem,Josh Gautney,Nicole Harris,Savannah Herder,Tamer Hudali,R Chad Wade,Rutwij Joshi,Daniel Kelmenson,Anne M Mason,Scott R Merriman,Takudzwa Mkorombindo,Megan Moore,Jada Nowak,Kate O'Connor,Sheylan D Patel,G Bruno Pereira,Lisa Sarratt,Tabitha Stewart,William S Stigler,Kadambari Vijaykumar,Gina White,Stephanie C Demasi,Laura E Goyack,Kristy K Ford,Trevor S Mattox,Taketo Watase,Layla Anderson,Alicia K Cupelo,Aaron J Lacy
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.22002
IF: 11.816
2021-12-28
JAMA
Abstract:Importance: For critically ill adults undergoing emergency tracheal intubation, failure to intubate the trachea on the first attempt occurs in up to 20% of cases and is associated with severe hypoxemia and cardiac arrest. Whether using a tracheal tube introducer ("bougie") increases the likelihood of successful intubation compared with using an endotracheal tube with stylet remains uncertain. Objective: To determine the effect of use of a bougie vs an endotracheal tube with stylet on successful intubation on the first attempt. Design, setting, and participants: The Bougie or Stylet in Patients Undergoing Intubation Emergently (BOUGIE) trial was a multicenter, randomized clinical trial among 1102 critically ill adults undergoing tracheal intubation in 7 emergency departments and 8 intensive care units in the US between April 29, 2019, and February 14, 2021; the date of final follow-up was March 14, 2021. Interventions: Patients were randomly assigned to use of a bougie (n = 556) or use of an endotracheal tube with stylet (n = 546). Main outcomes and measures: The primary outcome was successful intubation on the first attempt. The secondary outcome was the incidence of severe hypoxemia, defined as a peripheral oxygen saturation less than 80%. Results: Among 1106 patients randomized, 1102 (99.6%) completed the trial and were included in the primary analysis (median age, 58 years; 41.0% women). Successful intubation on the first attempt occurred in 447 patients (80.4%) in the bougie group and 453 patients (83.0%) in the stylet group (absolute risk difference, -2.6 percentage points [95% CI, -7.3 to 2.2]; P = .27). A total of 58 patients (11.0%) in the bougie group experienced severe hypoxemia, compared with 46 patients (8.8%) in the stylet group (absolute risk difference, 2.2 percentage points [95% CI, -1.6 to 6.0]). Esophageal intubation occurred in 4 patients (0.7%) in the bougie group and 5 patients (0.9%) in the stylet group, pneumothorax was present after intubation in 14 patients (2.5%) in the bougie group and 15 patients (2.7%) in the stylet group, and injury to oral, glottic, or thoracic structures occurred in 0 patients in the bougie group and 3 patients (0.5%) in the stylet group. Conclusions and relevance: Among critically ill adults undergoing tracheal intubation, use of a bougie did not significantly increase the incidence of successful intubation on the first attempt compared with use of an endotracheal tube with stylet. Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT03928925