Forget the Failure and Fight for the Future

Meini Han,Zili Zhang,Rob Law,Xianwei Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2019.102793

IF: 12.853

2020-01-01

Annals of Tourism Research

Abstract:•Users reduce their future effort after failures.•The forgetting effect mitigates the influence of failure on user future effort.•Managerial implications for online incentive design are offered.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Influence of Entrepreneurial Failure Experience on Subsequent Entrepreneurial Intention

Jingjing Xu,Hong Du

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ismot.2012.6679437

2012-01-01

Abstract:There are an increasing number of researchers realizing the vital importance of entrepreneurial failure's influence on subsequent entrepreneurial intention. Failure provides entrepreneurs a chance to learn and enhance relevant capacities. Through reviewing researchers regarding to failure and intention, this article suggests to expand and deepen the theory of entrepreneurial failure and subsequent intention via viewing failure as a short stage in ongoing entrepreneurial process, which provides researchers a new perspective for future direction.
Entrepreneurial failure, learning from the failure and new venturing performance

Huafeng Wang,Shengxiao Li,Junsheng Dou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2017.04.011

2017-01-01

Abstract:Entrepreneurial failure is an important learning scenario,even more important than the value of information to business success.The perspective of entrepreneurship research often ignore the failure,separates the relationship between failure and success.To better understand the core issue whether the experience of entrepreneurial failure would contribute to future business success or not,a theoretical model was constructed,about the relationship among entrepreneurial failure (EF),learning from the failure (LF) and new venture performance (NVP).And through an empirical research on 147 valid samples,the following conclusions have been found that the relationship among EF,LF and NVP showed a non-linear and inverted U-shape feature.Numbers and extent of entrepreneurs' previous failure(s) will be positively associated with the level of learning and the growth of their subsequent ventures,until up to a threshold point where it will be negatively associated with both of them.LF has a significantly positive impact on NVP,and plays the role of mediating effect between EF and NVP.The findings revealed that not all failures can be equivalently promote LF.Moderate failure is the best learning situation,and has the most learning value.Being good at learning from failure is the key to business success.
Creativity is Allowing for Failures: Leader Failure Tolerance and Employee Creativity

Shenjiang Mo,Siu Yin Cheung,Yaping Gong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2019.17258abstract

2019-01-01

Abstract:The creative process is inherently risky and prone to failure. To promote creativity, scholars and practitioners have advocated the importance of having team leaders who are tolerant of employees’ failures in creative activities. However, creativity research thus far has not explicitly examined the role of leader failure tolerance. To address this knowledge void, from the systems view of creativity we examine a cognitive mechanism known as bisociation, through which leader failure tolerance may influence the production of novel and useful ideas. We also examine the joint effects of leader failure tolerance and individual differences in goal orientation on creativity through bisociation. To achieve our research goal, we first develop and validate a measure of leader failure tolerance using two independent samples. Then, we test the hypothesized relationships using a sample of 210 research and development (R&D) teams comprising 632 employees. Results show that leader failure tolerance positively relates to employee creativity through bisociation. Furthermore, when leader failure tolerance is high, performance-proving goal orientation has a positive indirect effect on creativity via bisociation, while performance-avoiding goal orientation has a negative indirect effect on creativity via bisociation. Taken together, these insights have important implications for managers charged with delivering creativity.
Exploring the Influence of Failure Aversion on Learning From Project Failure: A Sensemaking Perspective

Liangting Zhang,Bin Wang,Xiaoxia Feng,Yue Zhang,Wenzhou Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.794390

IF: 3.8

2022-05-03

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:Although project failure is commonly considered a negative event, it can provide valuable resources for learning. Despite well documented research on the antecedents of learning from project failure at the individual level, individuals’ attitude toward failures, a relatively proximal antecedent of learning from failure, has attracted limited attention in organizational studies. To address this paucity of research, based on the sensemaking theory, in the current study we specifically focused on individuals’ failure aversion and explored how it would influence learning from failure through the process of arguing and expectation. Using a sample of 774 employees from R&D teams in China, our findings revealed that individuals’ failure aversion enhanced their learning from failure through inducing a loss-focused coping, but failure aversion negatively affected learning from failure through increasing the individuals’ perceived loss of self-esteem. We also found that individuals’ learning goal orientation (LGO) weakened the negative relationship between the loss of self-esteem and learning from failure; however, LGO did not moderate our hypothesized relationship between loss-focused coping and learning from failure. Our study extends the literature on learning from failure in two ways. First, it explores the learning from failure process at the individual level based on the sensemaking theory and second, it sheds light on the underlying cognitive mechanisms operating between failure aversion and learning from project failure.

psychology, multidisciplinary
Let's Try Before It's Too Late: How Status Fall Affect University Technology Licensing Overtime?

Jin Chen,Jizhen Li,Wesley Sine,Ximing Yin,Xirong Shen

2019-01-01

Abstract:Viewing status fall as a critical negative performance feedback, the firm and prospect theory predict that status fall propels organizations to take risks, explore, and innovate, whereas threat rig...
The Double-edged Sword Effect of Creativity Failure on Creativity

Yuhui Jiang,Yufan Shang,Malika Richards

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/amproc.2023.10949abstract

2023-01-01

Abstract:Why are some individuals able to generate creative products, despite repeated frustrating failures, while others are not? The relationship between creativity failure and individual outcomes is inconsistent in the current research. We use cognitive appraisal theory to explain these contradictory findings. We hypothesize that individual goal orientations play a pivotal role in explaining successful creative outcomes after repeated failed attempts. We construct a mediated moderation model in which cognitive appraisal is a mechanism to uncover the impact of failed attempts on individual creativity. Specifically, we found that individuals with a learning goal orientation will appraise creativity failure as a challenge, which in turn enhances creativity. However, individuals with a performance goal orientation will appraise creativity failure as a threat rather than a challenge, which ends up inhibiting creativity. Our study offers novel insights into the understanding of when, in the face of prior failures, individuals will make further efforts in creative activities.
Understand Failure for Effort Deficit in Competitions:Learned Helplessness in Sport

WANG Jin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-677x.2007.03.008

2007-01-01

Abstract:On the basis of motivational deficit and functional deficit of helplessness theories,this study to develop an integrative model in sport competitions through testing 6 theoretic hypotheses.Eighty university students participated into a free throwing competition to detect winning and failure.Then,they also completed a dart throwing task individually.A serial of correlational analyses and ANOVAs were conducted on cognitive activities,state of orientation,effort,and performance on the dart throwing.The result showed that the subjects in failure had more focused on the courses,felt less controllable,and had less effort expenditure on the dart throwing in compared to subjects winning.In addition,attribution styles have also found an influence on the second task.These findings are discussed in this article.
Learning from failure: The roles of self-focused feedback, task expectations, and subsequent instruction.

Sebahat Gok,Emily R. Fyfe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/xge0001632

2024-09-07

Journal of Experimental Psychology General

Abstract:Previous research indicates that failure feedback leads people to tune out from the task, which is detrimental to their learning (Eskreis-Winkler & Fishbach, 2019; Keith et al., 2022). The current work aims to identify ways to optimize learning from failure feedback. We conducted six preregistered experiments ( N = 1,306) to replicate and extend the findings from Eskreis-Winkler and Fishbach (2019) with novel tests of self-focused feedback, task expectations, and subsequent instruction. The detriments of failure feedback were replicated in Studies 1a, 1b, and 1c, which altered the focus of the feedback message to be self-focused (e.g., your answer) or task-focused (e.g., the answer). The detriments of failure feedback were also replicated in Study 2 when the task expectations were manipulated to easy versus hard. These results generally underscored the robustness of the results from the original study. However, Study 3 established boundary conditions. When it was a rule-based task and brief instructions on the rule were provided after feedback, there was no evidence of a detrimental effect of failure, and failure feedback, in some conditions, resulted in even better learning than success feedback for learning new material. We conclude that the tune-out reactions to failure during feedback disappear and may even be reversed when subsequent learning opportunities are provided. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved)

psychology, experimental
How Do Entrepreneurs and Their Ventures Benefit from Prior Setbacks: the Mediating Role of Attitude Towards Failure

Wenwei Zhang,Pek-Hooi Soh,Wenhong Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/02662426221118208

2022-01-01

International Small Business Journal Researching Entrepreneurship

Abstract:By integrating an experiential learning view into an attitude model, we propose that an entrepreneur’s attitude towards failure resulting from a prior setback experience can positively affect a new venture’s commitment to learning. Moreover, the entrepreneur may be exposed to indirect experiential information by gaining access to managerial ties in the venture industry, moderating the influence of prior setback experience on attitudes towards failure. We developed a conceptual model to account for the conditional and indirect effects of an entrepreneur’s setback experience on organisational commitment to learning through the entrepreneur’s attitude towards failure. Using structural equation modelling, we analysed a sample of 143 entrepreneurs located in Western China’s high-technology industrial development zones and found full support for our model. This study provides theoretical and empirical insights into the intertwined relationships between context-specific experiences, individual attitude development and venture outcomes in entrepreneurship.
Deciding for Future Selves Reduces Loss Aversion

Qiqi Cheng,Guibing He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01644

IF: 3.8

2017-01-01

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:In this paper, we present an incentivized experiment to investigate the degree of loss aversion when people make decisions for their current selves and future selves under risk. We find that when participants make decisions for their future selves, they are less loss averse compared to when they make decisions for their current selves. This finding is consistent with the interpretation of loss aversion as a bias in decision-making driven by emotions, which are reduced when making decisions for future selves. Our findings endorsed the external validity of previous studies on the impact of emotion on loss aversion in a real world decision-making environment.
An experimental manipulation of the value of effort

Hause Lin,Andrew Westbrook,Frank Fan,Michael Inzlicht

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-024-01842-7

IF: 24.252

2024-03-05

Nature Human Behaviour

Abstract:People who take on challenges and persevere longer are more likely to succeed in life. But individuals often avoid exerting effort, and there is limited experimental research investigating whether we can learn to value effort. We developed a paradigm to test the hypothesis that people can learn to value effort and will seek effortful challenges if directly incentivized to do so. We also dissociate the effects of rewarding people for choosing effortful challenges and performing well. The results provide limited evidence that rewarding effort increased people's willingness to choose harder tasks when rewards were no longer offered (near transfer). There was also mixed evidence that rewarding effort increased willingness to choose harder tasks in another unrelated and unrewarded task (far transfer). These heterogeneous results highlight the need for further research to understand when this paradigm may be the most effective for increasing and generalizing the value of effort.

psychology, experimental,neurosciences,multidisciplinary sciences
Linking Failure Feedback to Individual Creativity: The Moderation Role of Goal Orientation

Yimin He,Xiang Yao,Shuhong Wang,Jay Caughron

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10400419.2016.1125248

IF: 2.032

2016-01-02

Creativity Research Journal

Abstract:The sense-making theory of creativity is extended by identifying failure feedback as a process that shapes creative interpretations and actions. We also consider the moderating effect of goal orientation on the relationship between failure feedback and individual creativity, according to the sense-making theory. A 2-waves survey data from 345 R&D employees and their supervisors in five Chinese high-tech companies indicated: (a) supervisors’ failure feedback positively correlates with incremental and radical creative performance, (b) learning goal orientation strengthens the relationship between failure feedback and creativity, and (c) avoidance goal orientation attenuates the relationship between failure feedback and creativity. The findings suggest that goal orientations play roles in optimizing failure feedback effects on creativity outcomes.

psychology, multidisciplinary, educational
Future Work Self and Employee Creativity: The Mediating Role of Informal Field-Based Learning for High Innovation Performance

Qichao Zhang,Ming Guo,Long Ye,Shuzhen Liu,Zhenzhong Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/SU13031352

2021-01-28

Abstract:In today’s highly uncertain environment, the value of creativity and innovation are increasingly critical. How individuals could improve their creativity and innovation performance has become the focus of attention. Future work self as an intrinsic motivation factor plays an important role in creativity and innovation. Based on the self-consistency theory, this study integrated proactive personality and informal field-based learning (IFBL) to explore the relationship between future work self and employee creativity to increase innovation performance. It used data from 201 R&D department employees in China’s high-tech companies. The results show that future work self has a positive effect on employee creativity and that IFBL mediates the relationship between future work self and employee creativity. This process is then positively moderated by a proactive personality. This study’s results help clarify the formation mechanism of creativity from the perspective of intrinsic motivation and indicate that future work self can drive individuals’ creativity and innovation efforts, especially under the consistency of self-concept, motivation and personality. This research also emphasizes the importance of IFBL in improving individual creativity and further organizational innovation performance. Implications for theory and management to help improve creativity and innovation performance are then discussed in detail.

Education,Psychology,Business,Economics
Tomorrow will Be better: Gamers' expectation and game usage

Tzu-Ling Huang,Gen-Yih Liao,T.C.E. Cheng,Wei-Xuan Chen,Ching-I Teng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2023.108021

IF: 9.9

2023-11-11

Computers in Human Behavior

Abstract:Online games generate enormous revenues for game makers, but game makers encounter the difficulty in ensuring that in-game tasks are sufficiently challenging to elicit achievement satisfaction from gamers, while not excessively challenging to elevate frustration. To address this problem, we applied expectancy-value theory (EVT) to the online gaming context. Specifically, our study aims to examine how gaming frustration, gamers' need for achievement, and the expectation of gaming advancement jointly shape in-game achievement satisfaction and, by extension, increase actual game usage. To test our model, we collected survey and behavioral data from 848 participants, thus generating a two-wave, and two-source dataset. We found that gamers' evaluations of success probability (expectation of gaming advancement) prominently determined their expected value (in-game achievement satisfaction), thus enhancing their continued use, use frequency, and actual usage. Whereas traditional EVT assumes a single and stable probability of achievement with regard to an event, we argue that perceptions of the probability of gaming achievements in the immediate future (now) differ from perceptions of such achievements in the more distant future , with the latter being more influential. By contextualizing EVT, we offer guidance to game makers who aim to keep users engaged, suggesting that they should design challenging in-game tasks that also elicit the hope of future gaming achievements, resulting in continued use, use frequency, and sustained gameplay. We conclude by offering insights for the makers of online games.

psychology, multidisciplinary, experimental
Invest in Innovation or Not? How Managerial Cognition and Attention Allocation Shape Corporate Responses to Performance Shortfalls

Lerong He,Liying Huang,Guangqing Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/mor.2021.58

IF: 3.776

2021-10-01

Management and Organization Review

Abstract:ABSTRACT This study investigates the influence of managerial cognition and attention allocation on firms’ responses to negative performance feedback. We explore how managerial cognition, as shaped by managers’ experiences, connections, positions, and industry environments, affects underperforming firms’ attention allocation and, consequently, their decisions to invest in innovation. Utilizing a longitudinal sample of Chinese high-tech firms from 2009 to 2017, we find that firms increase investment in research and development (R&D) when performance falls below aspiration levels. We also document that underperforming firms are associated with an even larger R&D investment increase when their CEOs have an R&D or engineering background, serve simultaneously as the board chair, or are not politically connected. In addition, we highlight the moderating effects of industry competition and industry norms on the relationship between firm underperformance and R&D intensity. We conclude that managerial cognition affects firms’ allocation of attention to innovation as a solution for closing performance gaps and shapes corporate responses to negative performance feedback.

management
What experiences constitute failures? High school students' reflections on their struggles in STEM classes

Xiaodong Lin-Siegler,Benjamin J Lovett,Yiran Du,Kan Yamane,Keying Wang,Syntia Hadis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.14990

Abstract:Inculcating the capacity to adapt successfully to failures is essential for talent development in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields. Despite its importance, this capacity to learn from failure is among the least understood processes in the field of talent development. This study aims to investigate how students conceptualize and react to failures and whether there is a correlation between students' conceptualizations of failure, emotional reactions to it, and academic performance. We invited 150 high-achieving high school students to share, interpret, and label their most memorable struggles in their STEM classes. Most of their struggles focused on the learning process itself, such as poor understanding of the subject matter, insufficient motivation or effort, or adopting ineffective learning strategies. Poor performance outcomes, such as poor test scores and bad grades, were not mentioned as frequently as the learning process. Students who labeled their struggle experiences as failures tended to focus more on performance outcomes, whereas students who labeled their struggle experiences as neither failures nor successes focused more on the learning process. Higher-achieving students were also less likely to label their struggles as failures than less-high achievers. Implications for classroom instruction are discussed with a particular focus on talent development in STEM fields.
How to Leverage Predictive Uncertainty Estimates for Reducing Catastrophic Forgetting in Online Continual Learning

Giuseppe Serra,Ben Werner,Florian Buettner

2024-10-10

Abstract:Many real-world applications require machine-learning models to be able to deal with non-stationary data distributions and thus learn autonomously over an extended period of time, often in an online setting. One of the main challenges in this scenario is the so-called catastrophic forgetting (CF) for which the learning model tends to focus on the most recent tasks while experiencing predictive degradation on older ones. In the online setting, the most effective solutions employ a fixed-size memory buffer to store old samples used for replay when training on new tasks. Many approaches have been presented to tackle this problem. However, it is not clear how predictive uncertainty information for memory management can be leveraged in the most effective manner and conflicting strategies are proposed to populate the memory. Are the easiest-to-forget or the easiest-to-remember samples more effective in combating CF? Starting from the intuition that predictive uncertainty provides an idea of the samples' location in the decision space, this work presents an in-depth analysis of different uncertainty estimates and strategies for populating the memory. The investigation provides a better understanding of the characteristics data points should have for alleviating CF. Then, we propose an alternative method for estimating predictive uncertainty via the generalised variance induced by the negative log-likelihood. Finally, we demonstrate that the use of predictive uncertainty measures helps in reducing CF in different settings.

Machine Learning,Artificial Intelligence
The Effect of Different Failure View on Corporate Innovation

LEI Qiao-ling,ZHAO Geng-shen,DUAN Xin-min

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-2053.2004.z1.029

2004-01-01

Abstract:The key of corporate innovation in idea innovation , Among the idea innovation, changing failure view is very important but neglected . This paper analyze two Different Failure View : One is traditional view on failure that winner is king ,but failure is bandit, this hold back corporate innovation; the other is360 degree view on failure , that is look failure form all sides and visual angle, this can promote corporate innovation.
Learn to Forget: Memorization Elimination for Neural Networks.

Yang Liu,Zhuo Ma,Ximeng Liu,Jian Liu,Zhongyuan Jiang,Jianfeng Ma,Philip Yu,Kui Ren

2021-01-01

Abstract:Nowadays, with the rapidly exploding amount of user data, more companies choose to train various business-specified machine learning models, especially neural networks, to improve service quality. Nevertheless, the current machine learning application is still a one-way trip for the user data. As long as users contribute their data, there is no way to retreat the contribution. Such an irreversible setting has two potential risks: 1) from a legislative point of view, many national regulations emphasize that users should have the right to remove their personal data; 2) from a security point of view, the unintended memorization of a neural network increases the possibility of an adversary to extract user's sensitive information. To this end, memorization elimination for machine learning models becomes a popular research topic. Considering that there is no uniform indicator to evaluate a memorization elimination method, we explore the concept of membership inference and define a novel indicator, called forgetting rate. It well describes the transformation rate of the eliminated data from "memorized" to "unknown" after conducting memorization elimination. Furthermore, we propose Forsaken, a method that allows users to eliminate the unintended memorization of their private data from a trained neural network. The unintended memorization here is formed by the out-of-distribution but sensitive data inadvertently uploaded by users. Compared to prior work, our method avoids retraining, achieves higher forgetting rate, and causes less accuracy loss through a trainable dummy gradient generator.
Future thinking and managers' innovative behavior: an experimental study

Boris Eisenbart,Dan Lovallo,Massimo Garbuio,Matteo Cristofaro,Andy Dong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jkm-02-2022-0102

IF: 8.689

2022-11-18

Journal of Knowledge Management

Abstract:Purpose Does future thinking enhance managers' innovative behavior? This study aims to posit that the ability to project events while considering current/future variables and their development (i.e. future thinking) – inextricably linked with the knowledge creation process – may enhance the manager's accuracy and the number of potentially successful innovative ideas for organizations. Design/methodology/approach The authors use a between-group experiment to examine the innovation choices of 47 subjects with experience in evaluating the market potential of new products when asked to support or otherwise reject real-life innovation-related ideas. The authors test the accuracy of decisions made by participants primed to apply future thinking, practically implemented through abductive reasoning, in their decision-making. Findings The authors found a significant change in managers' innovative choices, with participants primed for future thinking making significantly more accurate decisions than the control group. Those participants both correctly chose innovation-related ideas with significant future potential and rejected ideas with limited potential that ultimately failed. Originality/value This study explores how future thinking enhances managers' innovative behavior in organizations. It provides empirical evidence on how future thinking, practiced through abductive reasoning, can work to foster innovative behavior, which is an antecedent of knowledge creation. Organizations that foster future thinking concurrently create knowledge, increasing their competitive advantage in the long run.

information science & library science,management

Forget the Failure and Fight for the Future

The Influence of Entrepreneurial Failure Experience on Subsequent Entrepreneurial Intention

Entrepreneurial failure, learning from the failure and new venturing performance

Creativity is Allowing for Failures: Leader Failure Tolerance and Employee Creativity

Exploring the Influence of Failure Aversion on Learning From Project Failure: A Sensemaking Perspective

Let's Try Before It's Too Late: How Status Fall Affect University Technology Licensing Overtime?

The Double-edged Sword Effect of Creativity Failure on Creativity

Understand Failure for Effort Deficit in Competitions:Learned Helplessness in Sport

Learning from failure: The roles of self-focused feedback, task expectations, and subsequent instruction.

How Do Entrepreneurs and Their Ventures Benefit from Prior Setbacks: the Mediating Role of Attitude Towards Failure

Deciding for Future Selves Reduces Loss Aversion

An experimental manipulation of the value of effort

Linking Failure Feedback to Individual Creativity: The Moderation Role of Goal Orientation

Future Work Self and Employee Creativity: The Mediating Role of Informal Field-Based Learning for High Innovation Performance

Tomorrow will Be better: Gamers' expectation and game usage

Invest in Innovation or Not? How Managerial Cognition and Attention Allocation Shape Corporate Responses to Performance Shortfalls

What experiences constitute failures? High school students' reflections on their struggles in STEM classes

How to Leverage Predictive Uncertainty Estimates for Reducing Catastrophic Forgetting in Online Continual Learning

The Effect of Different Failure View on Corporate Innovation

Learn to Forget: Memorization Elimination for Neural Networks.

Future thinking and managers' innovative behavior: an experimental study