Abstract:Trigeminal neuralgia (TN) is a rare, yet debilitating trigeminal pain disorder, with jolts of supramaximal-debilitating pain in one or more of the three trigeminal branches. Familial TN is now recognized, with a recent report describing several human genetic polymorphisms. One affected gene is the voltage-gated calcium channel, CaV3.2 (CACNA1H), with 19 polymorphisms first described. A recent study in PAIN by Gambeta-et-al (DOI:10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002651) is entitled "CaV3.2 calcium channels contribute to trigeminal neuralgia ". Here, I call into question their claim. My main arguments are 1)-3): 1) Gambeta-et-al studied 4/19 mutations reported in heterologous cellular expression, with two mutations showing gain-of-function of CaV3.2, two mutations not showing gain-of-function. Therefore the exemplary picks of familial TN-associated CaV3.2 mutations do not show a uniform change of channel function, such as gain-of-function. 2) In Gambeta-et-al, one gain-of-function mutation, CaV3.2(G563R) was directed to mouse trigeminal ganglion (TG) neurons, and their resulting hyperexcitability was demonstrated. A critical control of a non-gain-of-function channel was not included here, it was unclear whether neurons were separated by sex, and human sensory neurons were not used. Importantly, it is not clear that TG neurons are the critical cellular site of CaV3.2 mutations. 3) Gambeta-et-al used CaV3.2-/- pan-null knockout mice. Human TN-associated CaV3.2 mutations were not over-expressed. They used a infraorbital nerve constriction injury and measured facial heat hyperalgesia. CaV3.2-/- show a pain phenotype similar to control, yet are not affected by a CaV3-inhibitory compound, Z944. My argument is that when starting with TN-associated human mutations, use of a trigeminal neuropathic pain model is of limited value, and that human mutations have to be expressed against a mouse null background. Re thermal cue, Gambeta-et-al failed to study cold-evoked pain which is a TN clinical hallmark. Thus, Gambeta-et-al's 2022 PAIN-paper offers little new mechanistic evidence why CaV3.2 polymorphisms are associated with trigeminal neuralgia.

Title: 1 Effects of Familial Hemiplegic Migraine Type 1 Mutation T666m on Voltage-gated 2 Calcium Channel Activities in Trigeminal Ganglion Neurons 3 the Effects of T666m Mutation on Trigeminal Ca

Effects of Familial Hemiplegic Migraine Type 1 Mutation T666M on Voltage-Gated Calcium Channel Activities in Trigeminal Ganglion Neurons

Functional Analysis of A Migraine-Associated Tresk K+ Channel Mutation

Effects of Calcium-Binding Sites in the S2–S3 Loop on Human and Nematostella Vectensis TRPM2 Channel Gating Processes

Effect of Mitochondrial Trna(Lys) Mutation on the Clinical and Biochemical Characteristics of Chinese Essential Hypertensive Subjects

Voltage-dependent Anion Channel Involved in the Mitochondrial Calcium Cycle of Cell Lines Carrying the Mitochondrial DNA A4263G Mutation.

N1366S Mutation of Human Skeletal Muscle Sodium Channel Causes Paramyotonia Congenita

Clinical and Genetic Analysis of Essential Hypertension with Mitochondrial Trnamet 4435A>G and YARS2 Mutation.

Electrophysiological characterization of a CaV3.1 calcium channel mutation linked to trigeminal neuralgia

Functional properties of a disease mutation for migraine in Kv2.1/6.4 channels

A Pre-Existing Myogenic Temporomandibular Disorder Increases Trigeminal Calcitonin Gene-Related Peptide and Enhances Nitroglycerin-Induced Hypersensitivity in Mice

Mutations In Cytoplasmic Loops Of The Kcnq1 Channel And The Risk Of Life-Threatening Events Implications For Mutation-Specific Response To Beta-Blocker Therapy In Type 1 Long-Qt Syndrome

Mutation-Specific Risk in Two Genetic Forms of Type 3 Long QT Syndrome

Location of mutation in the KCNQ1 and phenotypic presentation of long QT syndrome.

Gene Mutation and Clinical Analysis in Machado-Joseph Disease

A Novel TFG C.793c>g Mutation in a Chinese Pedigree with Charcot‐Marie‐Tooth Disease 2

The identification of the key residues E829 and R845 involved in transient receptor potential melastatin 2 channel gating

ATP1A2 Mutations in Migraine: Seeing through the Facets of an Ion Pump onto the Neurobiology of Disease

GJB1 mutations c.212T>G and c.311A>C induce apoptosis and inwardly rectifying potassium current changes in X-linked Charcot-Marie-Tooth type 1

Mechanistic contribution of CaV3.2 calcium channels to trigeminal neuralgia pathophysiology not clarified

Ca V 3.2 calcium channels contribute to trigeminal neuralgia