Interactive comment on “Tornado-Scale Vortices in the Tropical Cyclone Boundary Layer: Numerical Simulation with WRF-LES Framework”

Liguang Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-2018-787-rc4
2018-01-01
Abstract:This paper describes the characteristics of relatively intense tornado-scale vortices in a high-resolution numerical simulation of a mature tropical cyclone under environmental conditions resembling those of Typhoon Matsa (2005). It is found that the simulated vortices have locations and basic properties that are broadly consistent with limited observations. An effort is made to classify the vortices into 3 distinct categories. In my view, the article is well organized and provides useful information that is adequately summarized in the abstract and section 7. Moreover, I did not catch any obvious mistakes of major consequence. On the other hand, I was somewhat disappointed not to see a rigorous analysis of the generation and decay of a tornado-scale vortex belonging to any of the 3 categories. High-resolution TC simulations showing tornado-scale vor-
What problem does this paper attempt to address?