Cars or Trucks ? The Impact of Discrete Attribute Basing in Fuel Economy Regulations ∗

Jianwei Xing

2017-01-01

Abstract:Attribute basing is a common regulatory strategy in environmental regulations: in an effort to reduce the externality-generating dimension of a product, regulations impose standards whose stringency is based on a secondary attribute. This study provides empirical evidence of the welfare consequences of attribute basing in the context of U.S. Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards. Throughout the history of CAFE, the policy stringency has been based on a discrete attribute: the classification of vehicles as either passenger cars or light trucks, with the latter being subject to a less stringent target. This differential treatment of cars and trucks has perverse implications as it potentially distorts the fleet composition and increases the tailpipe emissions and accident-related externalities due to a larger market share of light trucks. By estimating a structural model of vehicle demand and supply incorporating CAFE credit trading, this study simulates a counterfactual scenario by removing the standard split and finds that attribute basing results in a 4.9% increase in the sales of light trucks and a corresponding social welfare loss that translates into $2.83 billion in 2014. Attribute basing also leads to welfare redistribution among automakers: the U.S. domestic firms benefit from the attribute basing with a profit increase of 1.8% at the expense of Asian and European automakers with a profit loss of 1.5% and 4.0% respectively. ∗I am grateful to my advisers Shanjun Li, Panle Jia Barwick and Jura Liaukonyte for their continual guidance and support. I thank Benjamin Leard for data sharing and guidance for the demand estimation. This paper also benefits from comments from Eyal Frank, Ariel Ortiz-Bobea, Christy Yichen Zhou, Jing Li, Yiyi Zhou, Jonathan Hughes, Rhiannon Jerch, Cynthia Lin Lawell and seminar participants at Dyson Environmental Economics Student Workshop and Dyson School PhD Job Market Candidate Seminar at Cornell and Northeast Workshop on Energy Policy and Environmental Economics at Dartmouth. †PhD candidate, Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management, Cornell SC Johnson College of Business, Cornell University, jx82@cornell.edu.