J un 2 01 4 Comment on “ Complete O ( α 4 s ) QCD Corrections to Hadronic Z Decays ”

Sheng-Quan Wang,Xing-Gang Wu,Stanley J. Brodsky
2014-01-01
Abstract:A complete calculation of the O(αs) QCD corrections to the hadronic decay width of the Z-boson has recently been reported in Ref.[1]. The computation of the new high-order terms, especially the four-loop terms for the dominant non-singlet part can lead to a significant improvement in the precision of theoretical prediction for the Z-boson decay width and thus a new level of precision for the determination of αs(MZ). However, the pQCD analysis in Ref.[1] uses the conventional practice of simple guessing the renormalization scale and taking an arbitrary range to estimate the pQCD uncertainties. This procedure inevitably introduces an arbitrary theoretical systematic error in the predictions. For example, the estimated uncertainties in the components to the decay width are δΓNS=0.101 MeV, δΓ V S=0.0027 MeV, and δΓS=0.042 MeV if one varies the renormalization scale in the range μr ∈ [MZ/3, 3MZ] [1]. An additional theoretical problem is that two types of logarithmic terms appear related to the renormalization of the axial singlet contribution; i.e. ln(μr/MZ) and ln(μr/Mt). Thus the usual assumption that the renormalization scale only depends on MZ , but not the top quark mass, does not have a clear justification.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?