Variation of piezoelectric properties and mechanisms across the relaxor- like/ferroelectric spectrum in BiFeO3-(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3-PbTiO3 ceramics J.Bennett

J. Bennett,T. R. Shrout,S. J. Zhang,H. E. Owston,T. J. Stevenson,F. Esat,A. J. Bell,T. P. Comyn

2018-01-01

Abstract:1-x-y)BiFeO3-x(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3-yPbTiO3 piezoelectric ceramics were investigated across the compositional space and contrasted against the BiFeO 3-(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3 system, a spectrum of relaxor-like/ferroelectric behavior was observed. Structural and piezoelectric properties were found to be closely related to the PbTiO 3 concentration, below a critical concentration, relaxor-type behavior was observed. The mechanisms governing the piezoelectric behavior were investigated with the use of a number of techniques including structural, electrical and imaging techniques. X-ray diffraction established that long-range crystallographic order was promoted above a critical PbTiO 3 concentration, y > 0.1125. Commensurate with the structural analysis, electric-field induced strain responses showed electrostrictive behavior in the PbTiO3-reduced compositions, with increased piezoelectric switching in PbTiO 3-rich compositions. PUND analysis was used to confirm electric-field induced polarization measurements, elucidating that the addition of PbTiO 3 increased the switchable polarization and long-range ferroelectric ordering. PFM of the BiFeO 3-(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3-PbTiO3 system exhibited typical domain patterns above a critical PbTiO 3 threshold, with no ferroelectric domains observed in the lead-free system in the pseudocubic region. Doping of BiFeO3PbTiO3 has been unsuccessful in the search for high-temperature materials that offer satisfactory piezoelectric properties, however, this system demonstrates that the partial substitution of alternative end-members can be an efficacious method. The partial substitution of PbTiO3 into BiFeO3-(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3 enables long range crystallographic order, resulting in increased polar order and T C. he search for novel high-temperature piezoelectric ceramics can therefore exploit the accommodating nature of the perovskite family, which allows significant variance in chemical and physical character in the exploration of new solid-solutions. Introduction The ferroelectric and piezoelectric properties of lead zirconate titanate (PZT) have been exploited for both sensing and actuating for over 50 years in applications such as medical ultrasound, sonar systems and diesel fuel injectors [1]. A watershed moment in the advancement of electroceramics was the discovery of BaTiO 3 in 1945 which exhibits a perovskite structure that belongs to the general formula ABO 3 and is key to commercial ferroelectric and piezoelectric materials [2]. PZT also belongs to this family, its superior electrical properties are owed to a morphotropic phase boundary (MPB) between the PbZrO 3rich rhombohedral and the PbTiO 3-rich tetragonal symmetries [3]. This coupling between the two symmetries allows a significant electromechanical response which manifests as large electric-field induced piezoelectric strains. However, large electric-field induced electrostrictive strains can also be generated by relaxor ferroelectrics although these often suffer from poor temperature stability. PZT exhibits a ferroelectric-paraelectric phase transition temperature, T C, in the region of 386 °C at which point piezoelectric properties are lost, although practically this temperature is much reduced [4]. A canonical relaxor often cited is Pb(Mg 1/3Nb2/3) (PMN) [5], the electric-field induced strain response is dominated by the electrostrictive effect and characteristic behavior includes a diffuseness of the temperature dependent properties related to the polarization, such as a broad maximum in the permittivity accompanied with a shift in the T C toward higher temperatures and the suppression of permittivity with increasing frequency with no obvious transition at TMAX using x-ray diffraction or optical techniques [6]. The generally recognized origin of this behavior is associated with multiple cations sharing the same lattice-site, leading to a structural instability and frustration of long-range structural ordering . L u suggested that when multiple ions appear on the same site, local strain fields are created that suppresses long-range strain distortion of the unit cell. This frustrates long-range structure ferroelectric order and manifests as polar nano-regions (PNR). The precise nature of PNRs is still not fully understood due to the difficulty of experimental observation. It is agreed that PNR‟s are lower-symmetry structural regions embedded in a higher symmetry matrix i.e cubic. A number of systems have demonstrated a compositionally dependent crossover between conventional ferroelectric and relaxor type behaviors such as La-doped PZT, BMTPZ-PT and PMNPT [7–9]. Recently, the xBiFeO 3-(1-x)(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3 system has been fabricated [10 – 3], notably exhibiting a „pseudocubic‟ region where long-range crystallographic order is frustrated coupled with large electric-field induced strains dominated by the electrostrictive component. A series of publications [13-14] have elucidated the origin of the relaxor-like dielectric properties at high temperature across the compositional space, owed to MaxwellWagner relaxation rather than conventional relaxor behavior [16]. A high T C was identified in the BiFeO3-rich compositions (above 440 oC where x > 0.6), making it a potential candidate as a lead-free high-temperature piezoelectric An MPB similar to PZT is located between tetragonal and rhombohedral symmetrie s in the BiFeO3-PbTiO3 system at ~70 mol% BiFeO 3, a ferroelectric TC of 632oC is reported for this composition [17-18]. The c/a ratio of the tetragonal phase is ~1.18 at the MPB and this giant tetragonal distortion generates large internal stresses that can inhibit nucleation of new domains and suppress non-180o domain switching [19]. Saturated ferroelectric loops have not thus far been acquired in undoped compositions due to the prohibitively large coercive field, EC, and DC conductivity at high electric-fields is substantial [20]. In this study, a broad compositional space will be examined with respect to structural and electrical ordering, highlighting the transition from relaxor-like properties at the BiFeO 3(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3 end member to conventional ferroelectric behavior at the BiFeO 3-PbTiO3 end member and solid-solutions across the compositional space in between. Experimental Ceramic powders of the BF-KBT and BF-KBT-PT ternary system were prepared b y conventional solid-state synthesis as previously outlined [12] [21]. Powders were uniaxially pressed at 50 MPa in order to form pellets, followed by cold isostatic pressing at 300 MPa for 10 minutes to increase the green density of the unsintered pellets, these were subsequently sintered between 975oC-1070oC and 1035oC –1065oC for the PbTiO3-free and PbTiO3-derived compounds respectively. Pellets were then mechanically lapped to <1 mm ensuring that the sample was flat across the entire surface and electroded with a fire-on (550 °C) conductive silver paste (Gwent Group, UK) for electrical measurements. X-ray diffraction (Phillips X‟Pert MPD, Netherlands) was used to identify the crystal structure of each composition. Room temperature X-ray diffraction (XRD) scans in the range 20o < 2し < 60o were measured. This was undertaken on crushed and annealed powders in order to minimize the influence of surface effects such as texture and stress. A 5420 SPM (Agilent Technologies, USA) was used for PFM imaging. The tip utilized was a NSC14/ Ti-Pt probe with a tip radius of ~30 nm with scan times typically consisting of a few minutes. Room temperature polarization –electric field (PE), strain-electric field (xE) measurements of the BF-KBT compounds were performed with a Radiant ferroelectric test e in conjunction with a non-contact displacement probe (Radiant Technologies, USA). Positive-up–negative-down (PUND) measurements were also performed using a Radiant ferroelectric tester using methods outlined by Dolgos [22]. A pulse and delay of 1 second was used throughout as the parasitic contribution to ferroelectric switching was presumed to be relatively fast i.e. >1 second. In order to record the xE and PE measurements at elevated temperatures a linear variable differential transducer (LVDT) was used in line with a DSP SR830 lock-in amplifier (Stanford Research, USA) and a high voltage TREK 610C power supply (TREK, USA). A National Instruments Data Acquisition Card was used to record the data. Samples were placed in an oil bath with the LVDT fixture suspended in a convection furnace. The temperature was recorded at the sample using a thermocouple and samples were held at the set temperature for 10 minutes before measurements commenced. Relative permittivity was measured over a broad frequency range as a function of temperature using an Agilent 4192A, with a non-inductively wound furnace upon heating using a ramp rate of 3 oC/min. The poling conditions (electric field and temperature) were optimized for the various compositions, and varied between 4 –8kV/mm and 50–100 oC. The poling time was held constant at 10 min, after this the samples were removed from the hot oil. The piezoelectric charge coefficient d 33 was determined with a conventional Berlincourt meter (Piezotest PM300, London, UK). Results I. Overview of the Structural and Electrical Properties of the BiFeO3-(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3 Binary System The xBiFeO3-(1-x)(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3 system has recently been reported by a number of authors across the entire compositional space allowing for a reasonable overview. Based upon the recent reports it is apparent that the structural and electrical properties are heavily dependent upon processing. This section provides the current development and status of the structural and electrical properties of the BiFeO 3-(K0.5Bi0.5)TiO3 system. A simplified nomenclature will be used interchangeably in this section, for example BF-KBT 4060 relates to x = 0.4. Upon sintering geometrical density measurements were performed, the theoretical density was calculated by interpolating the densities of the end members, as reporte