Does In-Vivo Separation of the Hip Joint Occur during Gait in Patients with Well-functioning Metal-on-Polyethylene Total Hip Arthroplasty ?

Tsung-Yuan Tsai,Jing-Sheng Li,Shaobai Wang,Donna Moxley Scarborough,Henrik Malchau,Harry E. Rubash,Guoan Li,Young-Min Kwon
2014-01-01
Abstract:Introduction: Knowledge of accurate in-vivo kinematics of total hip arthroplasty (THA) during daily activities is critical for gaining insights into complications such as hip impingement, edge loading, wear and implant loosening. Previous studies have reported hip separations up to 3 mm in patients with metal-on-polyethylene (MoP) THA during the swing phase of gait. However, no studies evaluated the effects of weight bearing on hip separations in stance and swing phases during gait. This study aimed to quantify hip separations in patients with MoP-THA during gait and to compare the hip separations between stance and swing phases using a validated dual fluoroscopic imaging system (DFIS). Methods: Sixteen patients (3 men and 13 women, with 12 right and 8 left THAs) with a total of 20 cementless non-constrained MoP-THAs received CT scan for creation of surface models of the acetabular cup, femoral stem and the hip bones. Local coordinate systems of the cup were determined according to the cup opening plane and anatomic planes (Fig. 1). Each subject was asked to perform level walking on a treadmill under the DFIS surveillance. Three-dimensional surface models of the hip and two-dimensional fluoroscopic images were introduced into a virtual DFIS to determine the actual hip poses. The study protocol is in accordance with previously published validation study [1]. Six-degrees-of-freedom (6-DOF) kinematics of the implants and bones of the hip were then measured during the entire gait cycle using the DFIS technique. Translations of the femoral head center relative to the acetabular cup were determined during gait. As the previously published accuracy of measurement of hip translation using the DFIS technique is <1.0 mm, in the current study, hip separation was defined when a translation is larger than 1.0 mm. Paired-sample t-test was performed to compare the femoral head translations between the stance and swing phases (α = 0.05). Results: The average maximum hip translations were 0.48±0.14 mm for stance phase and 0.47±0.13 mm for swing phases during the treadmill gait in this patient group. The maximum hip translations across all the THAs were found to be 0.89 mm and 0.80 mm in swing and stance phases, respectively (Table 1). The average hip translations were 0.32±0.11 mm in stance phase and 0.33±0.11 mm in swing phase (Table 1). No significant differences were found in the maximum or average hip translations between stance and swing phases (P-value = 0.56, 0.24) (Table 1). No significant differences were found between right and left hip translations in the 4 bilateral THA patients (P-value = 0.18, 0.21). No specific trend was found in the femoral head translations during the gait (Fig. 1). The maximum hip translations in medial/lateral, in/out of the cup and anterior/posterior directions were 0.25±0.12 mm, 0.22±0.16 mm and 0.20±0.13 mm in stance phase, and 0.23±0.16, 0.27±0.16 and 0.21±0.16 mm in swing phase (Table 1). Discussion: Hip separation is an important factor that could lead to edge loading. This study evaluated the in-vivo hip joint separation during a complete gait cycle using DFIS. In contrast to previously reported data, our results demonstrated that there is no hip separation observed greater than 1 mm in well-functioning MoP-THA patients during gait. Furthermore, no significant difference was found between hip translations in stance and swing phases during gait. The magnitudes of hip translations were found to be within manufactory tolerance of the components, suggesting that in-vivo hip separation or “pistoning” [2] may be minimal in well-functioning MoP-THA patients. Future studies are required to elucidate in-vivo hip joint separation in THA patients with other bearing surfaces and during other physiological activities such as stair climbing. Significance: No hip joint separation greater than 1 mm was found in 20 well-functioning metal-on-polyethylene total hip arthroplasties in stance and swing phases of gait. Acknowledgments: NA References: [1] Tsai, T.-Y., et al., 2013, J Biomech, 46:1300-1304. [2] Lombardi, A.V., et al., 2000, J Arthroplasty, 15:702-709.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?