Abstract:Purpose Consequence prediction is an emerging topic in safety management concerning the severity outcome of accidents. In practical applications, it is usually implemented through supervised learning methods; however, the evaluation of classification results remains a challenge. The previous studies mostly adopted simplex evaluation based on empirical and quantitative assessment strategies. This paper aims to shed new light on the comprehensive evaluation and comparison of diverse classification methods through visualization, clustering and ranking techniques. Design/methodology/approach An empirical study is conducted using 9 state-of-the-art classification methods on a real-world data set of 653 construction accidents in China for predicting the consequence with respect to 39 carefully featured factors and accident type. The proposed comprehensive evaluation enriches the interpretation of classification results from different perspectives. Furthermore, the critical factors leading to severe construction accidents are identified by analyzing the coefficients of a logistic regression model. Findings This paper identifies the critical factors that significantly influence the consequence of construction accidents, which include accident type (particularly collapse), improper accident reporting and handling (E21), inadequate supervision engineers (O41), no special safety department (O11), delayed or low-quality drawings (T11), unqualified contractor (C21), schedule pressure (C11), multi-level subcontracting (C22), lacking safety examination (S22), improper operation of mechanical equipment (R11) and improper construction procedure arrangement (T21). The prediction models and findings of critical factors help make safety intervention measures in a targeted way and enhance the experience of safety professionals in the construction industry. Research limitations/implications The empirical study using some well-known classification methods for forecasting the consequences of construction accidents provides some evidence for the comprehensive evaluation of multiple classifiers. These techniques can be used jointly with other evaluation approaches for a comprehensive understanding of the classification algorithms. Despite the limitation of specific methods used in the study, the presented methodology can be configured with other classification methods and performance metrics and even applied to other decision-making problems such as clustering. Originality/value This study sheds new light on the comprehensive comparison and evaluation of classification results through visualization, clustering and ranking techniques using an empirical study of consequence prediction of construction accidents. The relevance of construction accident type is discussed with the severity of accidents. The critical factors influencing the accident consequence are identified for the sake of taking prevention measures for risk reduction. The proposed method can be applied to other decision-making tasks where the evaluation is involved as an important component.

The differentiation and decision matrix risk assessment of accident precursors and near-misses on construction sites

Exploration on Accident Inducements of Highway Construction and Its Pre-warning Management

A science mapping approach-based review of near-miss research in construction

A pre-control method in safety risk management of metro construction

Research on scenario deduction and emergency decision-making evaluation for construction safety accidents

A method for assessing the crossed risk of construction safety

Developing A Case-Based Reasoning Model for Safety Accident Pre-Control and Decision Making in the Construction Industry

The Combination of HFACS and Context-aware Technology for Personalized Safety Management on Construction Sites

An improved text mining approach to extract safety risk factors from construction accident reports

A Study on Predicting the Occurrence Probability of Safety Accidents of Major Work Type in Construction Work

A Method Based on the Theories of Game and Extension Cloud for Risk Assessment of Construction Safety: A Case Study Considering Disaster-Inducing Factors in the Construction Process

A Sensor-Based Method to Detect Near-Miss Struck-By on Construction Site

Use of Evidential Reasoning and AHP to Assess Regional Industrial Safety

Research on the construction safety risk assessment of prefabricated subway stations in China

Construction Safety Risk Assessment and Early Warning of Nearshore Tunnel Based on BIM Technology

A Method for Vehicle Collision Risk Assessment through Inferring Driver's Braking Actions in Near-Crash Situations

Research on accident early warning of metallurgical enterprises based on grey DEMATEL/ISM and Bayesian network

Comprehensive evaluation of classification: an empirical study on consequence prediction of construction accidents in China

Using text mining and multilevel association rules to process and analyze incident reports in China

A probabilistic quantitative risk assessment model for the long-term work zone crashes

Hazard-Specific Real-Time Integrated Safety Assessment