Effect of the Failed "Quasi-loyalty Program" on Customer Satisfaction
Xia WEI,Rungting TU,Zhimin ZHOU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0334.2017.03.010
2017-01-01
Journal of Management Science
Abstract:In recent years,a newly developed marketing practice has been gaining a lot of attention:a firm gives unexpected rewards to its customer after transaction,aiming at giving its customer a surprise so as to achieve higher satisfaction and gain longterm customer loyalty.However,even though these rewards (or gifts) are given to the customers unexpectedly,these rewards don't always achieve the intended effects,i.e.,pleasurable surprises,because the customers may or may not like the rewards received.In previous studies,researchers mainly focused on the "surprise" value of this type of marketing practice and few discussed the downsides and the associated risks of such practice,especially on how a firm should react and respond if the program fails.In our research,we explore the effects of failed "unexpected reward program" (referred to as "quasi-loyalty program" in this study) on customer satisfaction,taking into account of different consumption goals and various types of rewards given.Then we further propose coping strategies to reduce the associated risks of such program.Two studies were conducted and 969 university students from a large university were recruited to have our hypotheses tested.Study 1 was a 2 (consumption goals:utilitarian vs.hedonic) × 2 (reward types:utilitarian vs.hedonic) × 2 (end results of the quasi-reward program:success vs.failure) between-subject scenario design of a "service" consumption.The results showed that the satisfaction level of the utilitarian-oriented customers did not decrease even when the quasi-reward program failed.It suggested that to these customers,having the rewards was still "better than nothing";however,by contrast,customers with hedonic consumption goal showed a decreased satisfaction,and low tolerance for a failed unexpected reward.Study 2 was a 2 (consumption goals:utilitarian vs.hedonic) × 2 (reward types:utilitarian vs.hedonic) × 3 (end results of the quasi-reward program:success vs.failure vs.failure with reminders) between-subject scenario design of a "product" consumption.The results again showed that,for utilitarian-oriented customers,the failure of the quasi-loyalty program would not decrease their satisfaction;however,the failure would decrease the satisfaction of the hedonic-oriented customers.In addition,the negative evaluation of the unsuccessful surprise could be curbed if customers were led to focus more on the surprise itself,namely,to perceive surprise as an "extra gain".Our research enriches the understanding of the unexpected reward program (quasi-loyalty program) and extends the boundary conditions of the previous findings on the benefit congruency framework of the sales promotion effectiveness.Moreover,our research provides practical implications for firms to develop successful quasi-loyalty programs by understanding the consumption goals,reward types,consumer types and the associated risks,especially based on the service/product types provided.