XIAP inhibits autophagy via XIAP-Mdm 2p 53 signaling

Xing Huang,Zhengsheng Wu,Yide Mei,Mian Wu
2013-01-01
Abstract:All reviewers appreciate the concept of your study and acknowledge a potential interest to a wide audience. Nevertheless, they do raise a number of important concerns, and emphasize that a substantial revision of the manuscript will be required. I would like to highlight that following the suggestions of reviewer #1, the physiological relevance of your observations needs to be addressed. Furthermore, additional markers of autophagy should be examined throughout your analysis to strengthen your conclusions. In addition, it will also be crucial to rule out that the effects of XIAP on tumorigenesis are mediated by its anti-apoptotic functions. Finally, the XIAP-Mdm2 interaction data should be strengthened based on the constructive comments provided by referee #3.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?