The Importance of Educational Credentials : Schooling Decisions and Returns in Modern China ⇤

Alex Eble,Brown,Feng Hu

2015-01-01

Abstract:Government policy sets the number of years of schooling needed to attain educational credentials such as a high school diploma. We exploit a policy change in China to estimate the impact of this policy choice on schooling decisions and labor supply. The policy extended the length of primary school by one year and was rolled out gradually across China over 25 years. We show this has reallocated 850 billion person-hours from labor to schooling to date, as the vast majority of affected individuals chose to earn a credential despite the additional year in school this required. A key contribution of our paper is to estimate the returns to an additional year of schooling while holding highest credential constant. We find the year generates a two percent gain in monthly income, with somewhat higher returns for China’s disadvantaged. This is much smaller than most estimates which do not separate the returns to additional schooling from those to earning a credential. We show that the policy, while redistributive, has generated a likely net loss of tens of billions of dollars. We interpret these results through a model of signaling and human capital accumulation and conclude that a high signaling value of earning a credential, also known as “credentialism,” plays a crucial role in household schooling decisions and in the returns to schooling in modern China. ⇤Eble (corresponding author): Department of Economics, Brown University. 64 Waterman Street, Providence, RI 02912. Email: alexander_eble@brown.edu; Hu: Dongling School of Economics and Management, University of Science and Technology Beijing, 30 Xueyuan Road, Haidian District, Beijing, China 100083. Email: feng3hu@gmail.com. We would like to thank Andrew Foster, Emily Oster, and John Tyler for extensive feedback and guidance, and Alexei Abrahams, Anna Aizer, Dionissi Aliprantis, Marianna Battaglia, Natalie Bau, Nate Baum-Snow, Ken Chay, Andrew Elzinga, John Friedman, David Glancy, Nate Hilger, Rob Jensen, Melanie Khamis, Eoin McGuirk, Bryce Millett-Steinberg, Sri Nagavarupu, Gareth Olds, Anja Sautmann, Rajiv Sethi, Jesse Shapiro, Zach Sullivan, Felipe Valencia, and seminar participants at APPAM, Brown, Cornell, NEUDC, SOLE, and Wesleyan for helpful suggestions. Eble gratefully acknowledges support from the United States National Science Foundation through a Graduate Research Fellowship and an IGERT Fellowship, and financial and computing resources from the Brown University PSTC. Hu acknowledges financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (71373002, 71133003, 71420107023). All remaining errors are our own. JEL codes: I25, I26, J24, O15.