The Causal Effect of Education on Wages : Evidence from China ’ s Rural Industry

Haizheng Li,Aselia Urmanbetova
2003-01-01
Abstract:Estimating the causal effect of education on earnings continues to pose econometric challenges because of the unobserved ability heterogeneity and the possible attenuation bias caused by measurement errors. In this study, we used household survey data to investigate the effect of education on earnings in China’s rural industry by controlling for such biases. We identified a unique instrument based on the Chinese culture. In particular, because of the cultural preference for boys in rural China, the existence of brothers has a negative effect on the education attainment of a girl. However, such circumstances presumably have no effect on the girl’s inherent ability. Therefore, the sibling information can be used as an instrument to correct for the omitted ability bias. Moreover, we are able to assess the effect of measurement errors based on the information in the data. In addition to the regular 2SLS method, we also apply the more efficient GMM method in the estimation, and conduct statistical tests on the validity of family background variables as instruments. Based on the sample used, we find no significant attenuation bias in the OLS estimation, but the omitted ability bias appears to be substantial and overestimates the rate of return. While the OLS estimation gives a return of 7.1% for women, the results from Instrumental Variable estimations indicate that education has an insignificant effect on wages in China’s rural industry. J. E. L Code: I21, J31
What problem does this paper attempt to address?