Mg 2 +-dependent gating of MgtE channel underlies Mg 2 + homeostasis

Motoyuki Hattori,Norihiko Iwase,Noritaka Furuya,Tomoya Tsukazaki,Ryuichiro Ishitani,Michael Maguire,Koichi Ito,Andres Maturana
2009-01-01
Abstract:Thank you for submitting your manuscript for consideration by the EMBO Journal. It has now been seen by three referees whose comments are enclosed. As you will see, all three referees find your study interesting, appreciate the high quality of your data and are supportive of publication. However, there are some issues that would first need to be addressed. A major point, raised by all three referees, concerns the mutations generated within the pore of MgtE: you do not demonstrate whether these mutant proteins are expressed and properly folded, thus precluding conclusions from being drawn as to their functionality. Reviewer 1 also questions the nature of the solutions used for the electrophysiological assays, which do not represent the physiological situation. It would be important to address both these criticisms before we are able to consider publication.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?