Abstract:We examine differences among reanalysis high-cloud products in the tropics, assess the impacts of these differences on radiation budgets at the top of the atmosphere and within the tropical upper troposphere and lower stratosphere (UTLS), and discuss their possible origins in the context of the reanalysis models. We focus on the ERA5 (fifth-generation European Centre for Medium-range Weather Forecasts – ECMWF – reanalysis), ERA-Interim (ECMWF Interim Reanalysis), JRA-55 (Japanese 55-year Reanalysis), MERRA-2 (Modern-Era Retrospective Analysis for Research and Applications, Version 2), and CFSR/CFSv2 (Climate Forecast System Reanalysis/Climate Forecast System Version 2) reanalyses. As a general rule, JRA-55 produces the smallest tropical high-cloud fractions and cloud water contents among the reanalyses, while MERRA-2 produces the largest. Accordingly, long-wave cloud radiative effects are relatively weak in JRA-55 and relatively strong in MERRA-2. Only MERRA-2 and ERA5 among the reanalyses produce tropical-mean values of outgoing long-wave radiation (OLR) close to those observed, but ERA5 tends to underestimate cloud effects, while MERRA-2 tends to overestimate variability. ERA5 also produces distributions of long-wave, short-wave, and total cloud radiative effects at the top of the atmosphere that are very consistent with those observed. The other reanalyses all exhibit substantial biases in at least one of these metrics, although compensation between the long-wave and short-wave effects helps to constrain biases in the total cloud radiative effect for most reanalyses. The vertical distribution of cloud water content emerges as a key difference between ERA-Interim and other reanalyses. Whereas ERA-Interim shows a monotonic decrease of cloud water content with increasing height, the other reanalyses all produce distinct anvil layers. The latter is in better agreement with observations and yields very different profiles of radiative heating in the UTLS. For example, whereas the altitude of the level of zero net radiative heating tends to be lower in convective regions than in the rest of the tropics in ERA-Interim, the opposite is true for the other four reanalyses. Differences in cloud water content also help to explain systematic differences in radiative heating in the tropical lower stratosphere among the reanalyses. We discuss several ways in which aspects of the cloud and convection schemes impact the tropical environment. Discrepancies in the vertical profiles of temperature and specific humidity in convective regions are particularly noteworthy, as these variables are directly constrained by data assimilation, are widely used, and feed back to convective behaviour through their relationships with thermodynamic stability.

Sensitivity Analysis of Outgoing Radiation at the Top of the Atmosphere in the Ncep/mrf Model

Adjoint Sensitivity of the Earth's Radiation Budget in the NCEP Medium‐range Forecasting Model

Can Climate Sensitivity Be Estimated from Short-Term Relationships of Top-of-atmosphere Net Radiation and Surface Temperature?

Estimation of Surface Shortwave Radiation Components under All Sky Conditions: Modeling and Sensitivity Analysis

Estimations of Climate Sensitivity Based on Top-Of-Atmosphere Radiation Imbalance

A SENSITIVITY EXPERIMENT OF MESO-SCALE MODEL TO RADIATION

A Model For The Energy Budget Of The Atmosphere - Comparison With Data From The Earth Radiation Budget Experiment

Comparison between Satellite Water Vapour Observations and Atmospheric Models’ Predictions of the Upper Tropospheric Thermal Radiation

Climate Sensitivity to Cloud Optical Properties

Radiative constraints on the energy budget of the tropical atmosphere

Roles of Earth’s Albedo Variations and Top-of-the-Atmosphere Energy Imbalance in Recent Warming: New Insights from Satellite and Surface Observations

A Sensitivity Study of Radiative Fluxes at the Top of Atmosphere to Cloud-Microphysics and Aerosol Parameters in the Community Atmosphere Model CAM5

Tracing the physical signatures among the calculated global clear-sky spectral shortwave radiative flux distribution

Differences in Tropical High Clouds among Reanalyses: Origins and Radiative Impacts

Accounting for Several Infrared Radiation Processes in Climate Models

Robust Susceptibility of Cloud Cover and Radiative Effects to Biases in Retrieved Droplet Concentrations

Climate Sensitivity and Thermal Inertia

The Local Aerosol Emission Effect on Surface Shortwave Radiation and Temperatures

Distinct Roles of Land Cover in Regulating Spatial Variabilities of Temperature Responses to Radiative Effects of Aerosols and Clouds

Atmospheric sensitivity on land surface temperature retrieval using single channel thermal infrared remote sensing data: Comparison among models

Impact of Clouds on Surface Radiative Fluxes and Snowmelt in the Arctic and Subarctic