Representation of Political Discussions in Web Forums : A Cross-National Assessment

Hai Liang,Fei Shen
2012-01-01
Abstract:Gauging public opinion through user generated content (UGC) on social media has experienced an explosive growth in recent years. Although social media have been celebrated for the equality of public expression and large participants involved, the representativeness of online opinions was called into question. This study demonstrates that public expression on the internet is unequally distributed across issues and the interests of the vocal minority and silent majority exhibit a substantial discrepancy. Through a cross national analysis of web-based political discussion forums from 54 societies with 1,218,698 threads, this study found that the user generated content in web forums is socially constructed. The inequality in reply and view distribution and discrepancy between lurker and participants are structured by political system, culture values, and so on. All these findings suggest that online user generated content as another symbolic representation of reality cannot represent the general public opinion or even the opinions of general internet users. Furthermore, the social construction of political discussion on the internet indicates what measured through UGC and the survey results are two different things in nature.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?