Ablation of Smurf 2 reveals an inhibition in TGF-β signaling through mono-ubiquitination of Smad 3

Liu-Ya Tang,Motozo Yamashita,Nathan Coussens,Xiangchun Wang,Chuxia Deng,Steven Cheng,Ying Zhang
2011-01-01
Abstract:Thank you for submitting your manuscript on Smad3 monoubiquitination by Smurf2 for consideration by The EMBO Journal. We have now received the comments of three expert reviewers, copied below. While the referees consider your findings potentially interesting and the study overall well-done, they however raise serious concerns regarding the conclusiveness of the data and the experimental support for the main conclusions. The extent of this criticisms, I am afraid to say, appears to preclude publication in The EMBO Journal, at least in the present form. Nevertheless, given the interest in principle, I am willing to give you an opportunity to respond to the referees' criticisms through a revised version. It is however clear that for the manuscript to eventually become suitable for publication in these pages, a significant amount of revision effort will be required, and I also realize that not all of the requested manuscript may be technically feasible I would therefore also understand if you were to decide to rather publish the manuscript rapidly and without major changes elsewhere. Should you however decide to thoroughly revise the study for The EMBO Journal, I would in fact not insist on clarification of the underlying genetic redundancies among Smad-regulating ubiquitin ligases, nor on the absence of mouse phenotypes. What would however be absolutely required is a thorough mechanistic clarification on the cellular level, in particular to show that Smad3 is regulated by Smurf2 on the endogenous level in the absence of exogenous overexpression. It will also be essential to address the question of monovs. multi-monovs. poly-ubiquitination raised by all referees, and to clarify the impact of Smurf2 on Smad2 relative to Smad3. Finally, the referees are unconvinced by the present evidence for Smad3 monoubiquitination affecting signaling via complex disruption, and more compelling data will be needed to address this.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?