Comparison of paramics and getram / aimsun for its simulations

Tan Zhi,C. R. Long,Lee Der Horng
2005-01-01
Abstract:PARAMICS and GETRAM/AIMSUN are two microscopic traffic simulation tools that are capable of modelling the functions of Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS) in a large network. This paper compares the Version 4.0 of PARAMICS with Version 4.0 of GETRAM/AIMSUN, based on the experience gained in using them to model a network with an expresway and arterials. The simulation tools were compared in six aspects: user interface, network modelling capabilities, traffic behaviour, statistical output, runtime performance and other advanced features. Between the two software packages, GETRAM/AIMSUN has shown its strength in the ease of network coding, modelling bus transit systems, and basic functions in expressway traffic management system. On the other hand, PARAMICS has advantage over GETRAM/AIMSUN in its visually realistic graphical animation, better integration of the different functional modules, and offers a much more comprehensive Application Programmer Interface (API) for modelling of advanced and emerging ITS functions. INTRODUCTION In the transportation engineering profession, traffic simulation software is an important tool in helping to assess the performance of a traffic network with complex, stochastic but interacting components which are difficult, if not impossible to model analytically. If used correctly, simulation tools allows users to conduct in-laboratory experiments to evaluate the traffic performance of a network under the modeled scenarios in a fast and cost-effective way, without having to disrupt traffic operations in a real network and potentially compromise public safety. With the improvement in computational speed of microprocessors, size of memory and storage devices in computers and reduction in hardware cost in the past two decades, microscopic traffic simulation tools are becoming more popular. In recent years, in respond to the market demand for microscopic traffic simulation software which are capable of simulating many operational and proposed intelligent transportation systems (ITS) functions in a large network, several tools have been developed. Two of them are GETRAM and PARAMICS which are the subject of comparison in this paper. PARAMICS (PARAllel MICroscopic Simulation) is one of the earliest microscopic traffic simulation tool developed with ITS modeling capabilities. It was originally 1 Engineer, Traffic Management Dept., Land Transport Authority, Singapore. 2 Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, National University of Singapore. Email: cheu@nus.edu.sg. Tel: 6874-2153. Fax: 6779-1635. Corresponding author. 3 Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, National University of Singapore.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?