Expressiveness and Complexity of Subclasses of Quantified Boolean Formulas

Uwe Bubeck,Hans Kleine Büning,Anja Remshagen,Xishun Zhao

2010-01-01

Abstract:We give a brief overview of expressiveness and complexity results for a hierarchy of subclasses of quantified Boolean formulas with close connections to Boolean circuits and minimal unsatisfiability.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Resolution And Expressiveness Of Subclasses Of Quantified Boolean Formulas And Circuits

Hans Kleine Buening,Xishun Zhao,Uwe Bubeck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-02777-2_36

2009-01-01

Abstract:We present an extension of Q-Unit resolution for formulas that are not completely in clausal form. This b-unit resolution is applied to different classes of quantified Boolean formulas in which the existential and universal variables satisfy the Horn property. These formulas are transformed into propositional equivalents consisting of only polynomially many subformulas. We obtain compact encodings as Boolean circuits and show that both representations have the same expressive power.
An Extension of Deficiency and Minimal Unsatisfiability of Quantified Boolean Formulas

Hans Kleine Büning,Xishun Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3233/sat190032

2007-01-01

Journal on Satisfiability Boolean Modeling and Computation

Abstract:The notion of minimal unsatisfiability and minimal falsity will be extended to non-clausal and non-prenex quantified Boolean formulas. For quantified Boolean formulas in negation normal form we generalize the notion of deficiency to the so-called cohesion, which is 1+ the difference between the number of occurrences of the conjunction symbol ∧ and the number of existential and free variables. Further, we show that all the complexity results with respect to minimal unsatisfiability or minimal falsity known for formulas with fixed deficiency can be adapted to formulas with fixed cohesion. For example, (1) the minimal unsatisfiability of propositional formulas with fixed cohesion is still solvable in polynomial time and, (2) the minimal falsity of quantified Boolean formulas with cohesion 1 is solvable in polynomial time.
On Models for Quantified Boolean Formulas.

HK Buning,XS Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-25967-1_3

2004-01-01

Abstract:A quantified Boolean formula is true, if for any existentially quantified variable there exists a Boolean function depending on the preceding universal variables, such that substituting the existential variables by the Boolean functions results in a true formula. We call a satisfying set of Boolean functions a model. In this paper, we investigate for various classes of quantified Boolean formulas and various classes of Boolean functions the problem whether a model exists. Furthermore, for these classes the complexity of the model checking problem - whether a set of Boolean functions is a model for a formula - will be shown. Finally, for classes of Boolean functions we establish some characterizations in terms of quantified Boolean formulas which have such a model. For example, roughly speaking any satisfiable quantified Boolean Horn formula can be satisfied by monomials and vice versa.
Transformations Into Normal Forms For Quantified Circuits

Hans Kleine Buening,Xishun Zhao,Uwe Bubeck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-21581-0_20

2011-01-01

Abstract:We consider the extension of Boolean circuits to quantified Boolean circuits by adding universal and existential quantifier nodes with semantics adopted from quantified Boolean formulas (QBF). The concept allows not only prenex representations of the form for all x(1)there exists y(1)...for all x(n)there exists y(n) c where c is an ordinary Boolean circuit with inputs x(1),..., x(n), y(1),..., y(n). We also consider more general non-prenex normal forms with quantifiers inside the circuit as in non-prenex QBF, including circuits in which an input variable may occur both free and bound. We discuss the expressive power of these classes of circuits and establish polynomial-time equivalence-preserving transformations between many of them. Additional polynomial-time transformations show that various classes of quantified circuits have the same expressive power as quantified Boolean formulas and Boolean functions represented as finite sequences of nested definitions (NBF). In particular, universal quantification can be simulated efficiently by circuits containing only existential quantifiers if overlapping scopes of variables are allowed.
A Survey on Applications of Quantified Boolean Formulas

Ankit Shukla,M. Seidl,Armin Biere,Luca Pulina

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICTAI.2019.00020

2019-11-01

Abstract:The decision problem of quantified Boolean formulas (QBFs) is the archetypical problem for the complexity class PSPACE. Beside such theoretical aspects QBF also provides an attractive framework for encoding and solving various application problems ranging from symbolic reasoning in artificial intelligence to the formal verification and synthesis of computing systems. In this paper, we survey the different application areas that exploit QBF technology for solving their specific problems.

Mathematics,Computer Science
Equivalence Models for Quantified Boolean Formulas

Hans Kleine Büning,K. Subramani,Xishun Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10817-007-9067-0

2007-01-01

Journal of Automated Reasoning

Abstract:In this paper, we introduce the notion of models for quantified Boolean formulas. For various classes of quantified Boolean formulas and various classes of Boolean functions, we investigate the problem of determining whether a model exists. Furthermore, we show for these classes the complexity of the model checking problem, which is to check whether a given set of Boolean functions is a model for a formula. For classes of Boolean functions, we establish some characterizations in terms of classes of quantified Boolean formulas that have such a model.
Freely adding one layer of quantifiers to a Boolean doctrine

Marco Abbadini,Francesca Guffanti

2024-10-19

Abstract:We show how to freely add the first layer of quantifier alternation depth to a Boolean doctrine over a small base category. This amounts to a doctrinal version of Herbrand's theorem for formulas with quantifier alternation depth at most one modulo a universal theory. To achieve this, we characterize, within the doctrinal setting, the classes $A$ of quantifier-free formulas for which there is a model $M$ such that $A$ is precisely the class of formulas whose universal closure is valid in $M$.

Logic,Category Theory
Equivalence Structure of a Subclass of Minimal Unsatisfiable Formulas

Daoyun Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-5269.2001.02.001

2001-01-01

Abstract:the equivalence structure of a subclass (MAX(1)) of minimal unsatisfiable formulas is investigated. The var-renaming and the lit-renaming problems over MAX(1)is considered,both are solvable in O( n2) time.
Solving Quantified Boolean Formulas with Few Existential Variables

Leif Eriksson,Victor Lagerkvist,George Osipov,Sebastian Ordyniak,Fahad Panolan,Mateusz Rychlicki

2024-05-10

Abstract:The quantified Boolean formula (QBF) problem is an important decision problem generally viewed as the archetype for PSPACE-completeness. Many problems of central interest in AI are in general not included in NP, e.g., planning, model checking, and non-monotonic reasoning, and for such problems QBF has successfully been used as a modelling tool. However, solvers for QBF are not as advanced as state of the art SAT solvers, which has prevented QBF from becoming a universal modelling language for PSPACE-complete problems. A theoretical explanation is that QBF (as well as many other PSPACE-complete problems) lacks natural parameters} guaranteeing fixed-parameter tractability (FPT).

Computational Complexity,Artificial Intelligence
On Boolean Models for Quantified Boolean Horn Formulas

Hans Kleine Büning,K. Subramani,Xishun Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-24605-3_8

2003-01-01

Abstract:For a Quantified Boolean Formula (QBF) Phi = Q(phi), an assignment is a function M that maps each existentially quantified variable of Phi to a Boolean function, where phi is a propositional formula and Q is a linear ordering of quantifiers on the variables of Phi. An assignment M is said to be proper, if for each existentially quantified variable yi, the associated Boolean function f(i) does not depend upon the universally quantified variables whose quantifiers in Q succeed the quantifier of yi. An assignment M is said to be a model for Phi, if it is proper and the formula phi(M) is a tautology, where phi(M) is the formula obtained from 0 by substituting fi for each existentially quantified variable yi. We show that any true quantified Horn formula has a Boolean model consisting of monotone monomials and constant functions only; conversely, if a QBF has such a model then it contains a clause-subformula in QHORN boolean AND SAT.
Computational Complexity of Quantified Boolean Formulas with Fixed Maximal Deficiency.

Hans Kleine Buening,Xishun Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tcs.2008.07.022

IF: 1.002

2008-01-01

Theoretical Computer Science

Abstract:The paper investigates the computational complexity of quantified Boolean formulas with fixed maximal deficiency. The satisfiability problem for quantified Boolean formulas with maximal deficiency 1 is shown to be solvable in polynomial time. For k >= 1, it is shown that true formulas with fixed maximal deficiency k have models in which all Boolean functions can be represented as CNF formulas over at most 2(4k/3) universal variables. As a consequence, the satisfiability problem for QCNF formulas with fixed maximal deficiency is in NP and for fixed deficiency the minimal falsity problem is in D-P. For two subclasses of quantified Boolean formulas with PSPACE-complete evaluation problem, QEHORN and QE2-CNF, we show that for fixed deficiency the minimal falsity problem can be decided in polynomial time. (C) 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
On Quantifying Literals in Boolean Logic and Its Applications to Explainable AI

Adnan Darwiche,Pierre Marquis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1613/jair.1.12756

2021-10-12

Abstract:Quantified Boolean logic results from adding operators to Boolean logic for existentially and universally quantifying variables. This extends the reach of Boolean logic by enabling a variety of applications that have been explored over the decades. The existential quantification of literals (variable states) and its applications have also been studied in the literature. In this paper, we complement this by studying universal literal quantification and its applications, particularly to explainable AI. We also provide a novel semantics for quantification, discuss the interplay between variable/literal and existential/universal quantification. We further identify some classes of Boolean formulas and circuits on which quantification can be done efficiently. Literal quantification is more fine-grained than variable quantification as the latter can be defined in terms of the former. This leads to a refinement of quantified Boolean logic with literal quantification as its primitive.

Artificial Intelligence,Databases,Machine Learning,Logic in Computer Science
Classes of propositional UMU formulas and their extensions to minimal unsatisfiable formulas

Hans Kleine Büning

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tcs.2024.114538

IF: 1.002

2024-03-31

Theoretical Computer Science

Abstract:The class UMU consists of propositional formulas which are a union of minimal unsatisfiable formulas (MU formulas). The structural complexity of UMU formulas depends essentially on the type and degree of intertwining of the MU subformulas. Starting from class of formulas that consist only of clause (or variable) disjoint minimal unsatisfiable subformulas, we study various UMU subclasses given by weakening and these conditions. Generalizing an idea from [6] , we investigate a characterization of UMU formulas by whether they allow transformation into a MU formula by adding literals and/or clauses. It can be shown that simplicity in constructing of such extensions correlates with the degree of intertwining of the MU subformulas. For UMU formulas, however, we can give only extensions that have an exponential size in the worst case. The question of the existence of short MU combinations of MU-formulas by adding literals and clauses remains open.

computer science, theory & methods
COMPLEXITY RESULTS ON MINIMAL UNSATISFIABLE FORMULAS

Xishun Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/9789812772749_0022

2007-01-01

Journal on Satisfiability Boolean Modeling and Computation

Abstract:In this paper we will give a review of complexity results concerning minimal unsatisfiable (MU) formulas. At first we recall the complexity of classes of maximal MU formulas, marginal MU formulas, ect., and some classes which are closed under splitting. Then the complexity of detecting the existence of some simple MU subformulas, existence of homomorphisms between MU formulas is reported. Finally, we mention some generalizations to the minimal unsatisfiability.
Efficient Implementation of an Abstract Domain of Quantified First-Order Formulas

Eden Frenkel,Tej Chajed,Oded Padon,Sharon Shoham

2024-08-19

Abstract:This paper lays a practical foundation for using abstract interpretation with an abstract domain that consists of sets of quantified first-order logic formulas. This abstract domain seems infeasible at first sight due to the complexity of the formulas involved and the enormous size of sets of formulas (abstract elements). We introduce an efficient representation of abstract elements, which eliminates redundancies based on a novel syntactic subsumption relation that under-approximates semantic entailment. We develop algorithms and data structures to efficiently compute the join of an abstract element with the abstraction of a concrete state, operating on the representation of abstract elements. To demonstrate feasibility of the domain, we use our data structures and algorithms to implement a symbolic abstraction algorithm that computes the least fixpoint of the best abstract transformer of a transition system, which corresponds to the strongest inductive invariant. We succeed at finding, for example, the least fixpoint for Paxos (which in our representation has 1,438 formulas with $\forall^*\exists^*\forall^*$ quantification) in time comparable to state-of-the-art property-directed approaches.

Logic in Computer Science
Quantifier rewriting and equivalence models for quantified horn formulas

Uwe Bubeck,Hans Kleine Büning,Xishun Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/11499107_29

2005-01-01

Abstract:In this paper, quantified Horn formulas with free variables (QHORN*) are investigated. The main result is that any quantified Horn formula Φ of length |Φ| with free variables, |∀| universal quantifiers and an arbitrary number of existential quantifiers can be transformed into an equivalent formula of length O(|∀| ·|Φ|) which contains only existential quantifiers. Moreover, it is shown that quantified Horn formulas with free variables have equivalence models where every existential quantifier is associated with a monotone Boolean function. The results allow a simple representation of quantified Horn formulas as purely existentially quantified Horn formulas (∃HORN*). An application described in the paper is to solve QHORN*-SAT in O(|∀| ·|Φ|) by using this transformation in combination with a linear-time satisfiability checker for propositional Horn formulas.
The Complexity of Variable Minimal Formulas

ZhenYu Chen,BaoWen Xu,DeCheng Ding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11434-010-3127-2

2010-01-01

Chinese Science Bulletin

Abstract:Based on the common properties of logic formulas: equivalence and satisfiability, the concept of variable minimal formulas with property preservation is introduced. A formula is variable minimal if the resulting sub-formulas with any variable omission will change the given property. Some theoretical results of two classes: variable minimal equivalence (VME) and variable minimal satisfiability (VMS) are studied. We prove that VME is NP-complete, and VMS is in DP and coNP-hard.
On the Number of Quantifiers Needed to Define Boolean Functions

Marco Carmosino,Ronald Fagin,Neil Immerman,Phokion Kolaitis,Jonathan Lenchner,Rik Sengupta

2024-08-20

Abstract:The number of quantifiers needed to express first-order (FO) properties is captured by two-player combinatorial games called multi-structural games. We analyze these games on binary strings with an ordering relation, using a technique we call parallel play, which significantly reduces the number of quantifiers needed in many cases. Ordered structures such as strings have historically been notoriously difficult to analyze in the context of these and similar games. Nevertheless, in this paper, we provide essentially tight upper bounds on the number of quantifiers needed to characterize different-sized subsets of strings. The results immediately give bounds on the number of quantifiers necessary to define several different classes of Boolean functions. One of our results is analogous to Lupanov's upper bounds on circuit size and formula size in propositional logic: we show that every Boolean function on $n$-bit inputs can be defined by a FO sentence having $(1 + \varepsilon)n\log(n) + O(1)$ quantifiers, and that this is essentially tight. We reduce this number to $(1 + \varepsilon)\log(n) + O(1)$ when the Boolean function in question is sparse.

Logic in Computer Science,Computational Complexity
On the strictness of the quantifier structure hierarchy in first-order logic

Yuguo He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2168/LMCS-10%284%3A3%292014

2014-11-12

Abstract:We study a natural hierarchy in first-order logic, namely the quantifier structure hierarchy, which gives a systematic classification of first-order formulas based on structural quantifier resource. We define a variant of Ehrenfeucht-Fraisse games that characterizes quantifier classes and use it to prove that this hierarchy is strict over finite structures, using strategy compositions. Moreover, we prove that this hierarchy is strict even over ordered finite structures, which is interesting in the context of descriptive complexity.

Logic in Computer Science
Minimization for Generalized Boolean Formulas

Edith Hemaspaandra,Henning Schnoor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1104.2312

2011-04-13

Abstract:The minimization problem for propositional formulas is an important optimization problem in the second level of the polynomial hierarchy. In general, the problem is Sigma-2-complete under Turing reductions, but restricted versions are tractable. We study the complexity of minimization for formulas in two established frameworks for restricted propositional logic: The Post framework allowing arbitrarily nested formulas over a set of Boolean connectors, and the constraint setting, allowing generalizations of CNF formulas. In the Post case, we obtain a dichotomy result: Minimization is solvable in polynomial time or coNP-hard. This result also applies to Boolean circuits. For CNF formulas, we obtain new minimization algorithms for a large class of formulas, and give strong evidence that we have covered all polynomial-time cases.

Computational Complexity

Expressiveness and Complexity of Subclasses of Quantified Boolean Formulas

Resolution And Expressiveness Of Subclasses Of Quantified Boolean Formulas And Circuits

An Extension of Deficiency and Minimal Unsatisfiability of Quantified Boolean Formulas

On Models for Quantified Boolean Formulas.

Transformations Into Normal Forms For Quantified Circuits

A Survey on Applications of Quantified Boolean Formulas

Equivalence Models for Quantified Boolean Formulas

Freely adding one layer of quantifiers to a Boolean doctrine

Equivalence Structure of a Subclass of Minimal Unsatisfiable Formulas

Solving Quantified Boolean Formulas with Few Existential Variables

On Boolean Models for Quantified Boolean Horn Formulas

Computational Complexity of Quantified Boolean Formulas with Fixed Maximal Deficiency.

On Quantifying Literals in Boolean Logic and Its Applications to Explainable AI

Classes of propositional UMU formulas and their extensions to minimal unsatisfiable formulas

COMPLEXITY RESULTS ON MINIMAL UNSATISFIABLE FORMULAS

Efficient Implementation of an Abstract Domain of Quantified First-Order Formulas

Quantifier rewriting and equivalence models for quantified horn formulas

The Complexity of Variable Minimal Formulas

On the Number of Quantifiers Needed to Define Boolean Functions

On the strictness of the quantifier structure hierarchy in first-order logic

Minimization for Generalized Boolean Formulas