Experimental and Theoretical Challenges in the Search for the Quark–gluon Plasma: the STAR Collaboration's Critical Assessment of the Evidence from RHIC Collisions

J. R. Adams,M. M. Aggarwal,Z. Ahammed,J. Amonett,B. D. Anderson,D. Arkhipkin,G. S. Averichev,S.K. Badyal,Y. Bai,J. Balewski,O. Barannikova,L. S. Barnby,J. Baudot,S. Bekele,V. V. Belaga,A. Bellingeri-Laurikainen,R. Bellwied,J. Berger,B. I. Bezverkhny,Samarth Bharadwaj,A. Bhasin,A. K. Bhati,V.S. Bhatia,H. Bichsel,Jaroslav Bielcik,Jana Bielčı́ková,A. Billmeier,L. C. Bland,C. O. Blyth,B. E. Bonner,M. Botje,A. Boucham,J. Bouchet,A. V. Brandin,A. Bravar,M. Bysterský,R. V. Cadman,X. Z. Cai,H. Caines,Manuel Calderón de la Barca Sánchez,J. Castillo,O. Catu,D. Cebra,Z. Chajęcki,P. Chaloupka,S. Chattopadhyay,H. F. Chen,Y. Chen,J. Cheng,M. Cherney,A. Chikanian,W. Christie,J. P. Coffin,Thomas Michael Cormier,J. G. Cramer,H. J. Crawford,Debasish Das,S. Das,M. M. de Moura,T. G. Dedovich,A. A. Derevschikov,L. Didenko,Thomas Dietel,Sunil Dogra,W. J. Dong,X. Dong,J. E. Draper,Fei Du,A. K. Dubey,V. B. Dunin,J. C. Dunlop,M. R. Dutta Mazumdar,V. Eckardt,W. R. Edwards,L. G. Efimov,В. Емелянов,J. Engelage,G. Eppley,Barbara Ewa Erazmus,M. Estienne,P. Fachini,Julien Faivre,R. Fatemi,J. Fedorišin,K. Filimonov,P. Filip,E. Finch,V. Fine,Y. Fisyak,Jiang Fu,C. A. Gagliardi,L. Gaillard,J. Gans,M. S. Ganti,F. J. M. Geurts,V. Ghazikhanian,Premomoy Ghosh,J. E. Gonzalez,H. Gos,O. Grachov,O. G. Grebenyuk,D. Grosnick,S. M. Guertin,Y. Guo,Anik Gupta,T. D. Gutierrez,T. J. Hallman,A. Hamed,D. Hardtke,John William Harris,M. Heinz,T. W. Henry,S. Hepplemann,Boris Hippolyte,A. Hirsch,E. Hjort,G. W. Hoffmann,H. Z. Huang,S. Huang,E. W. Hughes,Thomas Humanic,G. Igo,A. Ishihara,Peter Martin Jacobs,W. W. Jacobs,Maciej Jedynak,H. Jiang,Peter G. Jones,E. G. Judd,S. Kabana,K. Kang,M. Kaplan,D. Keane,A. Kechechyan,V. Yu. Khodyrev,J. Kiryluk,A. Kisiel,E. M. Kislov,Jennifer Lynn Klay,S. R. Klein,D. D. Koetke,T. Kollegger,M. Kopytine,L. Kotchenda,M. Krämer,П. Кравцов,V. I. Kravtsov,K. Krueger,Christian Claude Kuhn,А. И. Куликов,Ajay Kumar,R. Kh. Kutuev,А. А. Кузнецов,M. A. C. Lamont,J. M. Landgraf,S. Lange,F. Laue,J. Lauret,A. Lebedev,R. Lednický,S. Lehocká,M. J. LeVine,C. Li,Q. Li,Y. Li,G. Lin,S. J. Lindenbaum,M. A. Lisa,F. Liu,H. Liu,L. Liu,Q. J. Lìu,Z. Liu,T. Ljubičić,W. J. Llope,H. Long,R. S. Longacre,M. Lopez-Noriega,W. A. Love,Y. Lu,T. Ludlam,D. Lynn,G. L.,J. G.,Y. G.,D. Magestro,S. Mahajan,D. P. Mahapatra,R. Majka,L. K. Mangotra,R. Manweiler,S. Margetis,C. Markert,Luis Miguel García Martín,J. N. Marx,H. S. Matis,Yu. A. Matulenko,C. J. McClain,T. S. McShane,F. Meißner,Yu. Melnick,A. Meschanin,Michael L. Miller,N. G. Minaev,Camelia Mironov,A. Mischke,D. Mishra,J. T. Mitchell,Bedangadas Mohanty,L. Molnár,C. F. Moore,Д. А. Морозов,Marcelo Gameiro Munhoz,Basanta Kumar Nandi,S. K. Nayak,T. K. Nayak,J. M. Nelson,Pawan Kumar Netrakanti,В. А. Никитин,L. V. Nogach,S. B. Nurushev,G. Odyniec,A. Ogawa,V. Okorokov,M. Oldenburg,D. Olson,S. K. Pal,A. I. Pavlinov,T. Pawlak,T. Peitzmann,V. Perevoztchikov,C. Perkins,W. Peryt,В. А. Петров,S. C. Phatak,R. Picha,M. Planinić,J. Pluta,N. Porile,J. Porter,A. M. Poskanzer,M. Potekhin,E. Potrebenikova,B. V. K. S. Potukuchi,D. Prindle,Claude Andre Pruneau,J. Putschke,Gregory Rakness,R. Raniwala,S. Raniwala,O. Ravel,R. L. Ray,S. V. Razin,D. Reichhold,J. G. Reid,J. Reinnarth,G. Renault,F. Retière,A. Ridiger,H. G. Ritter,Jay Roberts,O. V. Rogachevskiy,J. L. Romero,Andrew Rose,C. Roy,L. Ruan,M. J. Russcher,Raghunath Sahoo,I. Sakrejda,Sevil Salur,J. Sandweiss,M. Sarsour,I. Savin,P. S. Sazhin,J. Schambach,R. P. Scharenberg,N. Schmitz,Janet Elizabeth Seger,P. Seyboth,E. Shahaliev,M. Shao,W. Shao,M. Sharma,W. Q. Shen,K. E. Shestermanov,S. S. Shimanskiy,E. P. Sichtermann,F. Simon,R. N. Singaraju,N. Smirnov,Raimond Snellings,G. Sood,P. Sorensen,J. Sowiński,J. Speltz,H. M. Spinka,B. Srivastava,A. Stadnik,T. D. S. Stanislaus,R. Stock,A. Stolpovsky,M. Strikhanov,B. Stringfellow,Alexandre Alarcon Do Passo Suaide,E. Sugarbaker,Christophe Pierre Suire,M. Šumbera,B. Surrow,M. Swanger,T. J. M. Symons,A. Szanto de Toledo,A. Tai,Jun Takahashi,A. H. Tang,T. Tarnowsky,D. Thein,J. H. Thomas,Sergey Timoshenko,M. Tokarev,S. Trentalange,R. E. Tribble,O. D. Tsai,J. Ulery,T. Ullrich,D. G. Underwood,G. Van Buren,M. van Leeuwen,A. M. Vander Molen,R. Varma,I. M. Vasilevski,A. N. Vasiliev,Renaud Vernet,S. E. Vigdor,Y. P. Viyogi,S. Vokál,Sergey Voloshin,W. T. Waggoner,F. Wang,G. Wang,X. L. Wang,Y. Wang,Z. M. Wang,H. Ward,J. W. Watson,J. C. Webb,G. D. Westfall,A. Wetzler,C. Whitten,G. Wieman,S. W. Wissink,R. Witt,John Wood,Ji Wu,N. Xu,Z. Xu,E. Yamamoto,P. Yepes,V. I. Yurevich,H. Zborovsky,H. Zhang,W. M. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Z. P. Zhang,R. Zoulkarneev,Y. Zoulkarneeva,A. N. Zubarev
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2005.03.085
IF: 1.558
2005-01-01
Nuclear Physics A
Abstract:We review the most important experimental results from the first three years of nucleus-nucleus collision studies at RHIC, with emphasis on results from the STAR experiment, and we assess their interpretation and comparison to theory. The theory-experiment comparison suggests that central Au+Au collisions at RHIC produce dense, rapidly thermalizing matter characterized by: (1) initial energy densities above the critical values predicted by lattice QCD for establishment of a Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP); (2) nearly ideal fluid flow, marked by constituent interactions of very short mean free path, established most probably at a stage preceding hadron formation; and (3) opacity to jets. Many of the observations are consistent with models incorporating QGP formation in the early collision stages, and have not found ready explanation in a hadronic framework. However, the measurements themselves do not yet establish unequivocal evidence for a transition to this new form of matter. The theoretical treatment of the collision evolution, despite impressive successes, invokes a suite of distinct models, degrees of freedom and assumptions of as yet unknown quantitative consequence. We pose a set of important open questions, and suggest additional measurements, at least some of which should be addressed in order to establish a compelling basis to conclude definitively that thermalized, deconfined quark-gluon matter has been produced at RHIC.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?