Abstract:This study investigates the optimal process for locating generic service facilities by applying and comparing several well-known basic models from the literature. At a strategic level, we emphasize that selecting the right location model to use could result in a problematic and possibly misleading task if not supported by appropriate quantitative analysis. For this reason, we propose a general methodological framework to analyze and compare the solutions provided by several models to obtain a comprehensive evaluation of the location decisions from several different perspectives. Therefore, a battery of key performance indicators (KPIs) has been developed and calculated for the different models' solutions. Additional insights into the decision process have been obtained through a comparative analysis. The indicators involve topological, coverage, equity, robustness, dispersion, and accessibility aspects. Moreover, a specific part of the analysis is devoted to progressive location interventions over time and identifying core location decisions. Results on randomly generated instances, which simulate areas characterized by realistic geographical or demographic features, are reported to analyze the models' behavior in different settings and demonstrate the methodology's general applicability. Our experimental campaign shows that the p-median model behaves very well against the proposed KPIs. In contrast, the maximal covering problem and some proposed back-up coverage models return very robust solutions when the location plan is implemented through several progressive interventions over time.

Using the primitive cognitive network process for location analysis : comparisons with the analytic hierarchy process

The Primitive Cognitive Network Process: Comparisons With The Analytic Hierarchy Process

Decision models for information systems planning using primitive cognitive network process: comparisons with analytic hierarchy process

The Primitive Cognitive Network Process in healthcare and medical decision making: Comparisons with the Analytic Hierarchy Process

Towards logistics service provider selection strategy using primitive cognitive network process

Towards a ranking approach for sensor services using primitive cognitive network process

Fuzzy Cognitive Network Process: Comparisons with Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process in New Product Development Strategy.

Towards a hybrid approach of primitive cognitive network process and fuzzy cognitive map for box office analysis

Towards a hybrid approach of primitive cognitive network process and Bayesian network for evaluation

Towards a hybrid approach of Primitive Cognitive Network Process and Self-Organizing Map for computer product recommendation

Towards An Evaluation Strategy For Consumer Electronic Products Using Primitive Cognitive Network Process

Fuzzy-Analytic Hierarchy Process based Distribution Center Location Selection Research

Towards A Recommendation Approach For University Program Selection Using Primitive Cognitive Network Process

Analytic Network Process and Application for Supplier Selection

A fuzzy analytic network process for multi-criteria evaluation of contaminated site remedial countermeasures

Dealing with Uncertainty and Fuzziness in Development Planning: A Simulation of High-Technology Industrial Location Decisionmaking by the Analytic Hierarchy Process

Evaluating software component quality from vendors using the primitive cognitive network process with ISO/IEC 9126

Comparative analysis of models and performance indicators for optimal service facility location

The Research on the Location Selection of the Bank Outlets Based on Triangular Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process

The Interval Analytical Hierarchy Process on Location of Logistic Distribution Center

Supplier selection using analytic network process and data envelopment analysis