Using Lead Isotope Ratios to Distinguish between Samples of the Traditional Chinese Medicine

Chaoyong Yang,Zhiyong Huang

2002-01-01

Abstract:Quadrupole Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) was used to determine lead (Pb) isotope ratios in Dan-shen, a type of herb used in Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCM), and in water and soil samples all taken from the same geographical location. The precision obtained for the Pb/Pb ratio, the Pb/Pb ratio and the Pb/Pb ratio values was considerably lower than 0.5% demonstrating the applicability of the technique for Pb isotope ratio studies. The results show that it is possible to distinguish Dan-shen samples originating from different geographical areas using Pb isotope ratio measurements. As the medicinal effectiveness of a TCM is highly dependant on the source of origin of its herb components, it is useful to have a reliable, routine means of “fingerprinting” the components grown in different habitats. Introduction Most Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCMs) are a mixture of several different herbs that undergo special treatment to make them useful. The amounts of the effective components in the plants are influenced by the soil, water, weather conditions etc in the area where they are grown. Experienced practitioners of traditional Chinese healing know that the quality of herb medicines is strongly related to their source of origin. It is therefore important to know the specific location of a TCM herb component so ensure its effectiveness. Many techniques have been applied to characterize various herb medicines and to correlate them with their place of origin. High Performance Liquid Chromatography, Mass Spectrometry, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, Infrared Spectroscopy and X-ray Fluorescence have all been used to produce spectra that can be used to “fingerprint” the TCM habitat. Lead isotope ratio measurements provide analytical information relating to the source of lead contamination in naturally occurring samples. Concentration measurements cannot provide this information. Studies of the isotopic composition of lead are therefore commonly used in environmental science as well as geological and anthropological studies. Among all the naturally occurring lead isotopes, only Pb is non-radiogenic, whereas, Pb, Pb and Pb are the daughter products from the radioactive decay of U and U and Th respectively. As a consequence, small Pb isotope abundance variations occur in nature and the isotopic composition of lead in the environment is dependent on local ore deposits. If lead is present in the soil, a plant will take up small amounts and subsequent isotope ratio studies might provide a unique means of differentiating between different plant sources of origin. Of course, local lead levels may become mixed with external sources of contamination (e.g. automobile exhaust) that vary with time depending on the anthropogenic activity. These mixing processes can be quantified as long as each lead source shows a different lead isotope abundance. The work described in this application note was undertaken to investigate if lead isotope ratios can be used to “fingerprint” the Dan-shen herb grown in different habitats. While isotope ratio studies have traditionally been undertaken with a multicollector mass spectrometer such as Thermal Ionization Mass Spectrometry (TIMS), the technique is relatively slow and the instrumentation is expensive. These experiments were carried using quadrupole Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICPMS) that provides a fast, convenient and precise method to determine isotope ratios. The Agilent 7500 Series ICP-MS is an excellent tool for routine isotope ratio measurements. It is easy to operate with its fully automated optimization system (Auto-tune function) and its user-friendly software. Because of these advantages, Agilent ICP-MS systems have been widely used for isotope ratio studies for environmental monitoring applications and nuclear research projects, e.g., U isotope ratios in human urine , in the cooling water of nuclear plants etc., the certified values of some certified reference materials such as rock samples , biological samples [3,4] by isotope dilution. In Encinar et al.’s work, an older model Agilent ICP-MS (HP-4500) was used, and the performance was as good as the more expensive multi-collector ICP-MS and double focusing sector field ICP-MS especially for long term stability and isotope dilution applications.