Abstract:Ship exhaust emissions have been considered as a significant source of air pollution that has an adverse impact on the global climate and human health. It is of vital importance to create an accurate ship emission inventory for the purpose of formulating effective control measures. A wide range of inventory compilation methods have been proposed around the globe, and there has long been a pressing need to analyze and compare these methods in depth. This study sorted out and categorized inventory compilation methods of ship emissions in recent decades. Five main methods were compared and analyzed by their applicability, complexity, time of calculation, accuracy of results, etc. In addition, a new method was proposed to develop an emission inventory based on a vessel energy consumption reporting system. This method is believed to have the potential advantages to produce results of higher accuracy and temporal and spatial resolutions. To perform the validation, three cases at different scales were selected in part of China and surrounding maritime waters (large-scale), the Yangtze River Delta region (medium-scale), and Tianjin Port (small-scale), respectively. The analysis results show that: each of methods have different technical characteristics. Computed results significantly between methods, with the maximum deviation of up to 87%. It is advisable that the optimal method should be chosen based on the actual needs in inventory compilation and the data available. In terms of accuracy of results, Methods 1 and 5 offer moderately high accuracy; Method 2 provides average accuracy; while Methods 3 and 4 produce low accuracy. In terms of resolution of results, Methods 1 and 5 provide high-resolution temporal and spatial distribution of ship emissions; Method 2 delivers low-resolution spatial distribution; while Methods 3 and 4 are incapable of spatial distribution. In terms of applicability, Method 1 applies to the calculation of inventories of varying scales; Method 2 is more applicable to small-scale calculations, such as a port; Methods 3, 4, and 5 are more desirable for large-scale calculations, such as a country. The author recommends Methods 5, 1, 3, and 2/4 in a descending order of preference for large-scale ship emissions inventory compilations; recommends Method 5 (if accuracy is the first priority) or Method 1 (if temporal and spatial resolutions are given first priority), followed by Methods 2, 3, and 4 in a descending order of preference for small/medium-scale ship emissions inventory compilations. These results may serve to help inventory compilers choose an applicable method and support improvements in inventory compilation methods.

Review of methods and progress on shipping emission inventory studies

Carbon Emission Trading Scheme in the shipping sector: Drivers, challenges, and impacts

Comparative Analysis, Use Recommendations, and Application Cases of Methods for Develop Ship Emission Inventories

Progress in Research of Air Pollution Emissions from Ships

Shipping emissions and their impacts on air quality in China

Evolution of Green Shipping Research: Themes and Methods

A review of the port carbon emission sources and related emission reduction technical measures

National- to Port-Level Inventories of Shipping Emissions in China

Atmospheric Impacts and Regulation Framework of Shipping Emissions: Achievements, Challenges and Frontiers

Research on the carbon emissions traceability inventory and multi-horizon prediction of ship carbon emissions: a case study of Tianjin Port

Ship exhaust emission estimation and analysis using Automatic Identification System data: The west area of Shenzhen port, China, as a case study

Reviews on current carbon emission reduction technologies and projects and their feasibilities on ships

Real world emission characteristics of Chinese fleet and the current situation of underestimated ship emissions

Inland port vessel emissions inventory based on Ship Traffic Emission Assessment Model–Automatic Identification System

Ship energy consumption analysis and carbon emission exploitation via spatial-temporal maritime data

Analysis of the uncertainty of the AIS-based bottom-up approach for estimating ship emissions

A comprehensive review on countermeasures for CO2 emissions from ships

Ship emissions around China under gradually promoted control policies from 2016 to 2019

Evaluation of ship emission intensity and the inaccuracy of exhaust emission estimation model

An AIS-based emission inventory and the impact on air quality in Tianjin port based on localized emission factors

Targeting the Effectiveness Assessment of the Emission Control Policies on the Shipping Industry