Abstract:Since the reformation in Parks Canada conducted after 1994,it seems like that there is a trend that national park administration in Canada has a superficial similarity with protected area management in China because both of them are supported jointly by the government appropriation from tax collection and the revenue from tourism businesses.However,there are tremendous differences in protected area management between Canada and China,including government support,management institutions and conditions for the reformation.Based on the interviews with different level officials of Parks Canada system and field survey in five national/provincial parks in Canada,this article reviewed the reformation in national parks management of Canada by using new public management(NPM) theory and polarity management tool.According to the Canadian experiences,it is proved that NPM could be applied in the public sectors responsible for natural resources management.It was implemented to eliminate the disadvantages of bureaucratic management after its full development,including X-inefficiency and expanding expenditure.The main content of the reformation had two aspects:one was to remove the disadvantages of bureaucratic management by decentralization and introducing market tools;and the other was to maintain the advantages of bureaucratic management by the application of User Fee Principle and Cost Recovery Principle,the improvement of legislations and regulations system and the strengthening of monitoring system.In this way,the advantages of both bureaucratic and market-oriented management were combined to achieve the protection of ecological integration.However,the protected areas in China began to introduce market tools before the establishment of perfect bureaucratic management.Because of the problems of fund shortage,defective legislations and regulation system and absence of a consolidated organization responsible for protected area management,the disadvantages of market tools could not be controlled effectively.Compared with the experiences of Parks Canada,it is very difficult to take full advantage of market tools in protected area management before the establishment of a perfect legislation and regulation system and a consolidated organization.Therefore,it is recommended for China that the market tools should be highly cautiously applied into the protected area management unless three conditions have been achieved:(a)the establishment of perfect legislations and regulations system and its implementation;(b)more financial support from government to protected areas;and(c)a consolidated bureaucratic administration responsible for protected areas.

Comparative Study on Current Visitor Management Models for National Parks and Protected Areas

Rationality or morality? A comparative study of pro-environmental intentions of local and nonlocal visitors in nature-based destinations

The Implementation of New Public Management in National Parks of Canada and Its Reference to China

Comparison of Natural Tourism Planning Administration Modes Between Chinese Famous Scenic Sites and British National Parks-Taking Chinese Jiuzhaigou Valley Famous Scenic Sites and British New Forest National Park As Examples

Theoretical Framework and Differentiated Policies for National Park Zoning Management: A Baishanzu Case Study in China

Tourists’ spatio-temporal behaviour and concerns in park tourism: Giant Panda National Park, Sichuan, China

Model Analysis of Community Participation in Protection of China's Protected Areas Based on A Comparative Study of Six Cases

Visitors' Attitudes Towards China'S National Forest Park Policy, Roles and Functions, and Appropriate Use

Management Model for Mountain-type Tourism Resources:A Case Study of Zhangjiajie National Forest Park

A Comparative Study on Tourism System Models

Tourist Management Based On Behaviour Characteristics During Peak Travel Period - A Case Study Of Jiuzhaigou

Predictive Modeling of Transportation Systems in Jiuzhai Valley World Heritage Site, China

A multi-agent model of traffic simulation around urban scenic spots: From the perspective of tourist behaviors

Chinese national parks: Differences, resource use and tourism product portfolios

Current Situations And A Concept Model Of Buffer Zones Of Chinese National Parks

COMPARATIVE EVALUATION OF TOURISM SUSTAINABILITY BETWEEN NATIONAL PARKS IN THE UK AND CHINA——A Case Study of Jiuzhaigou National Park and New Forest National Park

Visitors’ Experience of Using Smart Facilities in Urban Parks: A Study in Shenzhen

Who behaves more pro-environmental in the national parks: A comparison of the tourist and the hiker

Preliminary Analysis on the Implementation Plans for the Chinese National Park Pilot Areas

Monitoring and management of high-end tourism in protected areas based on 3D sensor image collection

A Study on Spatiotemporal Evolution and Influencing Factors of Chinese National Park Network Attention