Political reservation and substantive representation: Evidence from Indian village councils

Lori Beaman,Esther Duflo,Rohini Pande,Petia Topalova

2010-01-01

Abstract:Female presence in India’s state and national legislatures hovers at 10percent. Concerns that this limits the political voice available to women have led to the introduction and subsequent passage of a Reservation Bill in the Upper house of the Indian Parliament (Times of India, March 9, 2010). The bill seeks to reserve 33 percent of India’s state and national legislature positions for women. If implemented, 181 out of the 543 National legislators and 1,370 out of the 4,109 State legislators will be women. Several studies demonstrate that men and women differ in their political and policy preferences (Edlund and Pande, 2002; Miller, 2008). Furthermore, as voters are typically unable to enforce full policy commitment by their legislator, implemented policies often reflect policymakers’ preferences (Besley and Coate, 1997; Pande, 2003). Political underrepresentation of women, thus, potentially biases policymaking away from female policy interests. These arguments provide important motivations for gender-based affirmative action policies. Consistent with this view, a number of studies find* We thank Catherine Lee for painstaking work on coding the transcripts and research assistance. We thank IPF participants and especially Devesh Kapur, Hari Nagarajan, and Suman Bery for comments. The views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and do not implicate the International Monetary Fund, its management, or Executive Board.