Superstition Makes You Less Deontological: Explaining the Moral Function of Superstition by Compensatory Control Theory

Chuanjun Liu,Jiangqun Liao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/rel0000316
2022-01-01
Psychology of Religion and Spirituality
Abstract:Based on compensatory control theory, superstition might have a compensatory control function for people's moral lives, especially in a nonreligious population. The present study investigated the relationship between seeking control sense from superstition and deontological judgment, as well as two mediators: "hell belief" and "prayer intention." Hell belief and prayer intention partially mediated the relationship between seeking control sense from superstition and deontological judgment, indicating that seeking control sense from superstition decreased deontological judgment both directly and indirectly through superstitious belief or intention, such as hell belief and prayer intention. These findings demonstrate that the compensatory control function of superstition does not qualitatively change but does quantitatively decrease people's deontological inclination, which can function in a preventive way (e.g., hell belief) and/or a promotive way (e.g., prayer intention). The current study expands compensatory control theory to explain the moral function of superstition in nonreligious populations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?