Abstract:Social media have become central places where public discourses are generated, sustained, and circulated around public events. So far, much research has examined large-scale dissemination patterns of prominent statements, opinions, and slogans circulated on social media, such as the analysis of keywords and hashtags on Twitter regarding a political event. However, little attention has been paid to understanding how local socio-cultural-political conditions influence the formation and development of public discourses on social media. To explore this question, we analyzed public discourses about Hong Kong’s Umbrella Movement on two distinct social media sites, Facebook and Weibo, the largest micro-blogging service in China. Facebook topped Hong Kong citizens’ usage of social media sites, while Weibo’s primary user base is mainland Chinese. The social movement and these two social media sites provide a unique opportunity to explore the commonalities and differences between social media discourses generated by two different cultures. Using grounded theory and discourse analysis, we reveal how people on two sites reasoned about the many incidents of the movement and developed sometimes similar but other times strikingly different discourses. We trace the links between different discourses and the socio-cultural-political conditions of Hong Kong and mainland China. We discuss how this study may contribute deeper understandings of public discourses on social media to the CSCW literature.

Social Movements in Taiwan and Hong Kong

A “Two-Level Social Capital Analysis” of the Role of Online Communication in Civic Activism: Lessons From the Role of Facebook in the Sunflower Movement

One Social Movement, Two Social Media Sites: A Comparative Study of Public Discourses

Digital Disobedience and the Limits of Persuasion: Social Media Activism in Hong Kong’s 2014 Umbrella Movement

Social Movements As a Dialogic Process: Framing, Background Expectancies, and the Dynamics of the Anti-CNN Movement

Affordances, movement dynamics, and a centralized digital communication platform in a networked movement

When the Internet meets collective action: The traditional and creative ways of political participation in China

A Freirean Analysis of the Youth Social Movements in Hong Kong

Characterizing and modeling the dynamics of cyber movements

Organizational Mobilization and Political and Economic Movement: the Model of Community Work in Urban China in the 1960s and 1970S

The Political Power of Social Media:A Perspective on Collective Action Theories

Variations in media framing of movements in China, France, and the U.S.: An intersectional approach

The power of digital activism for transnational advocacy: Leadership, engagement, and affordance

Mobile Communication and Relational Mobilization in China

From Moment to Movement: Empowerment and Resilience as a Framework for Collective Action in Hong Kong

Internet and Activism in Urban China: A Case Study of Protests in Xiamen and Panyu

Dual Mediation and Success of Environmental Protests in China: a Qualitative Comparative Analysis of 10 Cases

Cyberactivism and Collective Agency: Cases from China.

The construction and mobilization of political consumerism through digital media in a networked social movement

Disagreement resolution on digital communication platform in a self-directed political consumerism campaign

A Moderated Mediation Model of Political Collective Action in Hong Kong: Examining the Roles of Social Media Consumption and Social Identity