The Dutch moral foundations stimulus database: An adaptation and validation of moral vignettes and sociomoral images in a Dutch sample

Frederic R. Hopp,Benjamin Jargow,Esmee Kouwen,Bert N. Bakker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/jdm.2024.5

2024-01-01

Judgment and decision making

Abstract:Abstract Moral judgments are shaped by socialization and cultural heritage. Understanding how moral considerations vary across the globe requires the systematic development of moral stimuli for use in different cultures and languages. Focusing on Dutch populations, we adapted and validated two recent instruments for examining moral judgments: (1) the Moral Foundations Vignettes (MFVs) and (2) the Socio-Moral Image Database (SMID). We translated all 120 MFVs from English into Dutch and selected 120 images from SMID that primarily display moral, immoral, or neutral content. A total of 586 crowd-workers from the Netherlands provided over 38,460 individual judgments for both stimuli sets on moral and affective dimensions. For both instruments, we find that moral judgments and relationships between the moral foundations and political orientation are similar to those reported in the US, Australia, and Brazil. We provide the validated MFV and SMID images, along with associated rating data, to enable a broader study of morality.

psychology, multidisciplinary

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to effectively evaluate moral judgment in the Dutch - speaking environment. Specifically, the researchers hope to adapt and validate two existing moral stimulation tools - Moral Foundations Vignettes (MFVs) and Socio - Moral Image Database (SMID) to study moral judgment among the Dutch population. Through the adaptation and validation of these tools, the researchers aim to:

1. **Translation and cultural adaptation**: Translate 120 MFVs from English into Dutch and adjust them to ensure their applicability in the Dutch cultural context.
2. **Image selection and validation**: Select 120 images mainly showing moral, immoral or neutral content from SMID and validate them through Dutch samples.
3. **Cross - cultural comparison**: Explore whether the moral judgment of the Dutch population is similar to the research results in the United States, Australia and Brazil, especially in terms of the relationship between moral foundations and political tendencies.
4. **Provision of resources**: Provide the validated MFVs and SMID images and their associated scoring data to the research community for broader research on moral issues.

Through these efforts, the researchers hope to better understand people's moral intuitions and judgments in different cultural backgrounds, thereby promoting cross - cultural research in moral psychology.