Unveiling the geographical distribution and publication strategies of non-conventional literature data on bird breeding biology in Brazil

Vítor André Rodrigues,André de Camargo Guaraldo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s43388-024-00173-5
2024-03-06
Ornithology Research
Abstract:Non-conventional literature refers to documents that are hardly acquired through the usual publishing channels, thus with limited circulation, and are often referred to as unpublished. While only ~ 30% of the world's bird species breeding biology is well known, such information may likely be found in these documents. Thus, we aimed to provide more visibility to bird breeding biology data found in the non-conventional literature, plus assessing its cross-country patterns and peer-review publication strategies. We ran a review of the non-conventional literature studies on the subject in the Brazilian public research institutes' databases ( n = 149) and synthesized all data found into a dataset. Our review confirmed the existence of several "unpublished studies", thus we checked for their distribution throughout the Brazilian research institutes and for any geographical biases in the studied sites. We also performed a series of descriptive analyses and generalized linear models (GLM) based on 98 studies. We found that institutes set in the Federal District, São Paulo, and Paraná carried out most of the research. The probability of publication of the data was higher for Passeriformes and data derived from theses and dissertations, but publication probabilities remained similar among Federal and State Universities. We end up by discussing the publication outputs of different bird groups and research institutes, likely due to pressures set by funding agencies, and urging for a call on greater sampling efforts and methodological innovation to increase the publication rate of bird breeding data and reduce the existing knowledge gaps in the scientific literature.
ornithology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?