Disease Severity Staging System for NOTCH3-Associated Small Vessel Disease, Including CADASIL.
Gido Gravesteijn,Julie W Rutten,Minne N Cerfontaine,Remco J Hack,Yi-Chu Liao,Amy A Jolly,Stéphanie Guey,Shao-Lun Hsu,Jae-Young Park,Yun Yuan,Anna Kopczak,Nicola Rifino,Sam J Neilson,Anna Poggesi,Md Manjurul Islam Shourav,Satoshi Saito,Hiroyuki Ishiyama,Ana Domínguez Mayoral,Renata Nogueira,Elena Muiño,Pia Andersen,Nicola De Stefano,Gustavo Santo,Nontapat Sukhonpanich,Francesco Mele,Ashley Park,Jung Seok Lee,Mar Rodríguez-Girondo,J,Amy Brodtmann,Anne Börjesson-Hanson,Leonardo Pantoni,Israel Fernández-Cadenas,Ana Rita Silva,Vinícus V A Montanaro,Rajesh N Kalaria,Diego Lopergolo,Masafumi Ihara,James F Meschia,Keith W Muir,Anna Bersano,Francesca Pescini,Marco Duering,Jay Chol Choi,Chen Ling,Hyunjin Kim,Hugh S Markus,Hugues Chabriat,Yi-Chung Lee,Saskia A J Lesnik Oberstein
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamaneurol.2024.4487
IF: 29.907
2024-01-01
JAMA Neurology
Abstract:Importance:Typical cysteine-altering NOTCH3 (NOTCH3cys) variants are highly prevalent (approximately 1 in 300 individuals) and are associated with a broad spectrum of small vessel disease (SVD), ranging from early-onset stroke and dementia (cerebral autosomal dominant arteriopathy with subcortical infarcts and leukoencephalopathy [CADASIL]) to nonpenetrance. A staging system that captures the full NOTCH3-SVD severity spectrum is needed and currently lacking. Objective:To design a simple disease severity staging system that captures the broad clinicoradiological NOTCH3-SVD severity spectrum. Design, Setting, and Participants:A cohort study was performed in which the NOTCH3-SVD severity staging system was developed using a discovery cohort (2019-2020) and validated in independent international CADASIL cohorts (1999-2023) and the UK Biobank. Clinical and imaging data were collected from participants originating from 23 international CADASIL cohorts and from the UK Biobank. Eligibility criteria were presence of a NOTCH3cys variant, availability of brain magnetic resonance imaging, and modified Rankin Scale score. The discovery cohort consisted of 195 NOTCH3cys-positive cases from families with CADASIL; the validation set included 1713 NOTCH3cys-positive cases from 15 countries. The UK Biobank cohort consisted of 101 NOTCH3cys-positive individuals. Data from 2-year (2019-2023) and 18-year (1999-2017) follow-up studies were also analyzed. Data analysis was performed from July 2023 to August 2024. Main Outcomes and Measures:Percentage of cases following the sequence of events of the NOTCH3-SVD stages, and the association between the stages and ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage, global cognition, processing speed, brain volume, brain microstructural damage, and serum neurofilament light chain (NfL) level. Results:The NOTCH3-SVD staging system encompasses 9 disease stages or substages, ranging from stage 0 (premanifest stage) to stage 4B (end stage). Of all 1908 cases, which included 195 in the discovery cohort (mean [SD] age, 52.4 [12.2] years) and 1713 in the validation cohorts (mean [SD] age, 53.1 [13.0] years), 1789 (94%) followed the sequence of events defined by the NOTCH3-SVD staging system. The NOTCH3-SVD stages were associated with neuroimaging outcomes in the NOTCH3cys-positive cases in the CADASIL cohorts and in the UK Biobank and with cognitive outcomes and serum NfL level in cases from the CADASIL cohorts. The NOTCH3-SVD staging system captured disease progression and was associated with 18-year survival. Conclusions and Relevance:The NOTCH3-SVD staging system captures the full disease spectrum, from asymptomatic individuals with a NOTCH3cys variant to patients with end-stage disease. The NOTCH3-SVD staging system is a simple but effective tool for uniform disease staging in the clinic and in research.