Abstract:To help reliability of SSD arrays, Redundant Array of Independent Disks (RAID) are commonly employed. However, the conventional reliability models of HDD RAID cannot be applied to SSD arrays, as the nature of failures in SSDs are different from HDDs. Previous studies on the reliability of SSD arrays are based on the deprecated SSD failure data, and only focus on limited failure types, device failures, and page failures caused by the bit errors, while recent field studies have reported other failure types including bad blocks and bad chips, and a high correlation between failures. In this paper, we explore the reliability of SSD arrays using field storage traces and real-system implementation of conventional and emerging erasure codes. The reliability is evaluated by statistical fault injections that post-process the usage logs from the real-system implementation, while the fault/failure attributes are obtained from field data. As a case study, we examine conventional and emerging erasure codes in terms of both reliability and performance using Linux MD RAID and commercial SSDs. Our analysis shows that a) emerging erasure codes fail to replace RAID6 in terms of reliability, b) row-wise erasure codes are the most efficient choices for contemporary SSD devices, and c) previous models overestimate the SSD array reliability by up to six orders of magnitude, as they focus on the coincidence of bad pages and bad chips that roots the minority of Data Loss (DL) in SSD arrays. Our experiments show that the combination of bad chips with bad blocks is the major source of DL in RAID5 and emerging codes (contributing more than 54% and 90% of DL in RAID5 and emerging codes, respectively), while RAID6 remains robust under these failure combinations. Finally, the fault injection results show that SSD array reliability, as well as the failure breakdown is significantly correlated with SSD type.

SSD Failures in Datacenters

An In-Depth Study Of Correlated Failures In Production Ssd-Based Data Centers

Measurement and Analysis of SSD Reliability Data Based on Accelerated Endurance Test

Investigating Power Outage Effects on Reliability of Solid-State Drives

Predicting solid state drive reliability

The Life and Death of SSDs and HDDs: Similarities, Differences, and Prediction Models

NVMe and PCIe SSD Monitoring in Hyperscale Data Centers

Evaluating Reliability of SSD-Based I/O Caches in Enterprise Storage Systems

NVMe SSD Failures in the Field: the Fail-Stop and the Fail-Slow

Improving the accuracy, adaptability, and interpretability of SSD failure prediction models

How does SSD Cluster Perform for Distributed File Systems: An Empirical Study

What Can We Learn from Four Years of Data Center Hardware Failures?

Review on HDD-SSD hybrid storage

General Feature Selection for Failure Prediction in Large-scale SSD Deployment

Rain or Shine? — Making Sense of Cloudy Reliability Data

A Large-Scale Study of I/O Workload's Impact on Disk Failure.

An Experimental Study of Redundant Array of Independent SSDs and Filesystems

Exploit Both SMART Attributes and NAND Flash Wear Characteristics to Effectively Forecast SSD-based Storage Failures in Clusters.

Chameleon: an Adaptive Wear Balancer for Flash Clusters

A Survey on the Approaches of Building Solid State Disk Arrays

A Modeling Framework for Reliability of Erasure Codes in SSD Arrays