Abstract:We have read with interest the comment of McDermott et al.1 on our article “Short pulse width widens the therapeutic window of subthalamic neurostimulation”.2 While the authors provide an elegant and sophisticated argument trying to prove our data wrong, they disregard a simple rule of experimentation from the viewpoint of theoretical biophysics: Deep brain stimulation systems do not have a “charge knob” to control the output of the neurostimulator. As correctly pointed out by McDermott et al., charge is the product of pulse duration and current. Both variables are controlled independently by the programmer and may be used to improve the selectivity of neurostimulation within a mixed nervous tissue containing target elements of deep brain stimulation (DBS) as well as side-effect elements. Our article describes from a clinical and experimental point of view, how to use the chronaxie relationship in clinical programming in order to avoid typical side effects of neurostimulation such as dysarthria or impaired fine motor skills by inadvertent stimulation of the pyramidal tract. In this experiment, the impact of a single variable (pulse duration) on the outcome variable current was assessed based on a threshold response. Their revised graph was simply showing the theoretical relationship between charge and pulse duration (which is trivial, because charge is the product of current amplitude and pulse duration as pointed out above), but was not experimentally assessed. We have a long experience in teaching novel programmers in adjusting the parameters of neurostimulation, which turns out to be a difficult task for clinicians, and had to perform multiple troubleshooting sessions ourselves in patients with poorly programmed DBS systems. The theoretical sophisticism of McDermott et al. adds confusion rather than providing a much needed practical guideline for DBS programming. We emphasize based on our experimental data and our clinical experience that DBS systems should be programmed treating pulse duration as a “constant” fixed at a low value (30–60 μsec depending on the hardware used) while using current or voltage for “dosing” the therapeutic response irrespective of any theoretical charge-pulse duration relationship.

Construction of Luffa Sponge-Based Magnetic Carbon Nanocarriers for Laccase Immobilization and Its Application in the Removal of Bisphenol A.

Immobilization of laccase on magnetic PEGDA-CS inverse opal hydrogel for enhancement of bisphenol A degradation in aqueous solution

Immobilization of Laccase on Magnetic Chelator Nanoparticles for Apple Juice Clarification in Magnetically Stabilized Fluidized Bed

Removal of Nanoplastics from Aqueous Solution by Aggregation Using Reusable Magnetic Biochar Modified with Cetyltrimethylammonium Bromide

Immobilization of laccase on magnetic mesoporous silica as a recoverable biocatalyst for the efficient degradation of benzo[a]pyrene

Construction of Bacterial Laccase Displayed on the Microbial Surface for Ultrasensitive Biosensing of Phenolic Pollutants with Nanohybrids-Enhanced Performance.

An efficient material (Mn-Cu-AC/cellulose beads) for immobilizing laccase: excellent activity, high stability and effective pollutant removal rate

Enhancing enzymatic catalysis efficiency: Immobilizing laccase on HHSS for synergistic bisphenol A adsorption and biodegradation through optimized external surface utilization

Chernobyl accident: reconstruction of thyroid dose for inhabitants of the Republic of Belarus.

Laccase immobilized on functionalized cellulose nanofiber/alginate composite hydrogel for efficient bisphenol A degradation from polluted water

Construction of copper-manganese based aminoclays with significant laccase-like activity and its prominent degradation performance towards bisphenol A

Micro-nano bubbles assisted laccase for biocatalytic degradation of bisphenols

Reply to comment on: Short pulse width widens the therapeutic window of subthalamic neurostimulation

Preparation,Characterization and Degradation to BPA of Pomegranate-like Gel Microsphere Entrapmented Laccase

Catalyzed degradation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons by recoverable magnetic chitosan immobilized laccase from Trametes versicolor

[Contrast ultrasonography: a technological advancement at the service of the patient].

Spacer arm of ionic liquids facilitated laccase immobilization on magnetic graphene enhancing its stability and catalytic performance

The Grammar of the Tic in Gilles de La Tourette's Syndrome

In-Situ Fabrication Of Functionalized Starch Magnetic Nanoparticles For Immobilization Of Laccase

Laccase immobilization on core-shell magnetic metal-organic framework microspheres for alkylphenol ethoxylate compound removal

Enhanced pollutant degradation via green-synthesized core-shell mesoporous Si@Fe magnetic nanoparticles immobilized with metagenomic laccase