Abstract:The structural design of self-supporting transmission line towers (TLTs) typically employs first-order elastic analysis to streamline practical engineering. Accordingly, due to their serial industrial production, prototype tests are often conducted to validate the adopted simplifications. Alternatively, developing robust and reliable nonlinear structural models to simulate progressive collapse could reduce the need for costly and time-consuming prototype test programs. In addition, a more comprehensive failure description is achieved by treating the mechanical model parameters as random variables. This approach leads to describing the load factor associated with tower collapse through probability density functions instead of relying on a single deterministic value. Although significant progress has been made in modeling the progressive collapse of lattice TLTs using both deterministic and stochastic approaches, critical gaps in this field remain unexplored. For instance, the existing literature has not yet addressed the modeling of stiffness degradation caused by residual stresses in tower angle sections, even in a deterministic approach. Furthermore, the few studies employing state-of-the-art structural models (e.g., including the bolt slippage effect) while simultaneously considering uncertainties have been limited to assessing numerical models without full-scale experimental validations. Hence, the present paper presents a novel structural model uncertainty assessment for the failure analysis of lattice TLTs. Originality arises from including the stiffness degradation caused by residual stresses in a numerical simulation that addresses all the remaining modeling complexities influencing tower collapse. Yet, the numerical framework is validated using three pre-existing prototype tests of TLTs available to the authors. For this purpose, up to eight distinct structural models are constructed, progressively incorporating different modeling complexities. This methodology allows for an examination of the impact of each modeling aspect on tower collapse simulation. The results indicate that numerical predictions align with prototype test results only when all modeling features are incorporated. In this scenario, the corresponding experimental load factors fall within the range determined by the uncertainty analysis. Finally, the proposed failure analysis tool is readily adaptable to assess other pertinent real-world engineering applications, including the cascading collapse of complete transmission line segment models under wind or seismic loads.

Sensitivities of the seismic response and fragility estimate of a transmission tower to structural and ground motion uncertainties

Seismic fragility analysis of transmission towers considering effects of soil-structure interaction and depth-varying ground motion inputs

Some Results on the Vulnerability Assessment of HAWTs Subjected to Wind and Seismic Actions

Bayesian Approach for Typhoon-Induced Fragility Analysis of Real Overhead Transmission Lines

Quantification of the Seismic Behavior of a Steel Transmission Tower Subjected to Single and Repeated Seismic Excitations Using Vulnerability Function and Collapse Margin Ratio

Lifetime multi-hazard fragility analysis of transmission towers under earthquake and wind considering wind-induced fatigue effect

Fragility analysis and assessment of large-span beam string-structures

Fragility analysis of a transmission tower under combined wind and rain loads

Shake table test and seismic fragility analysis of transmission tower-line system considering duration effect

Comprehensive seismic performance analyses of pile-supported transmission tower-line systems considering ground motion spatial variation and incident direction

Fragility analysis and wind directionality-based failure probability evaluation of transmission tower under strong winds

Fragility analysis of a transmission tower-line system subjected to wind and ice loads considering fatigue damage

Seismic response study of a steel lattice transmission tower considering the hysteresis characteristics of bolt joint slippage

Model uncertainty applied to the failure analysis of transmission towers

Seismic fragility analysis of nuclear power plants considering structural parameter uncertainty

Seismic Response and Collapse Analysis of a Transmission Tower Structure: Assessing the Impact of the Damage Accumulation Effect

Seismic Fragility Analysis of Three-Tower Cable-Stayed Bridges with Different Connection Configurations

Two-Scale Probabilistic Seismic Fragility Assessment for a Prestressed Concrete-Steel Hybrid Wind Turbine Tower with Incremental Dynamic and Multiple Stripe Analysis

Efficient seismic fragility analysis considering uncertainties in structural systems and ground motions

Effects of various modeling uncertainty parameters on the seismic response and seismic fragility estimates of the aging highway bridges

Fragility analysis of a long-span transmission tower–line system under wind loads