Abstract:Educational and Psychological Measurement, Ahead of Print. Rapid-guessing behavior in data can compromise our ability to estimate item and person parameters accurately. Consequently, it is crucial to model data with rapid-guessing patterns in a way that can produce unbiased ability estimates. This study proposes and evaluates three alternative modeling approaches that follow the logic of the effort-moderated item response theory model (EM-IRT) to analyze response data with rapid-guessing responses. One is the two-step EM-IRT model, which utilizes the item parameters estimated by respondents without rapid-guessing behavior and was initially proposed by Rios and Soland without further investigation. The other two models are effort-moderated multidimensional models (EM-MIRT), which we introduce in this study and vary as both between-item and within-item structures. The advantage of the EM-MIRT model is to account for the underlying relationship between rapid-guessing propensity and ability. The three models were compared with the traditional EM-IRT model regarding the accuracy of parameter recovery in various simulated conditions. Results demonstrated that the two-step EM-IRT and between-item EM-MIRT model consistently outperformed the traditional EM-IRT model under various conditions, with the two-step EM-IRT estimation generally delivering the best performance, especially for ability and item difficulty parameters estimation. In addition, different rapid-guessing patterns (i.e., difficulty-based, changing state, and decreasing effort) did not affect the performance of the two-step EM-IRT model. Overall, the findings suggest that the EM-IRT model with the two-step parameter estimation method can be applied in practice for estimating ability in the presence of rapid-guessing responses due to its accuracy and efficiency. The between-item EM-MIRT model can be used as an alternative model when there is no significant mean difference in the ability estimates between examinees who exhibit rapid-guessing behavior and those who do not.

Identifying Effortful Individuals With Mixture Modeling Response Accuracy and Response Time Simultaneously to Improve Item Parameter Estimation

A Mixture Response Time Process Model for Aberrant Behaviors and Item Nonresponses

A Mixture Cure-Rate Model for Responses and Response Times in Time-Limit Tests

A Mixture Model for Random Responding Behavior in Forced-Choice Noncognitive Assessment: Implication and Application in Organizational Research

Concurrent Use of Response Time and Response Accuracy for Detecting Examinees with Item Preknowledge

A Mixture Fluency model using responses and response times with cognitive diagnosis model framework

Enhancing Effort-Moderated Item Response Theory Models by Evaluating a Two-Step Estimation Method and Multidimensional Variations on the Model

A Constrained Factor Mixture Model for Detecting Careless Responses that is Simple to Implement

Detecting Aberrant Behavior and Item Preknowledge: A Comparison of Mixture Modeling Method and Residual Method

A Model-Based Approach to the Disentanglement and Differential Treatment of Engaged and Disengaged Item Omissions

Modeling Rapid Guessing Behaviors in Computer-Based Testlet Items

Contributions to the statistical analysis of item response time in educational testing

A Mixture Response Model for Identifying Item Preknowledge

An introduction to mixture item response theory models

Semiparametric Factor Analysis for Item-Level Response Time Data

A nonparametric Bayesian item response modelling approach for clustering items and individuals simultaneously

Joint Maximum Likelihood Estimation for High-dimensional Exploratory Item Response Analysis

A Two-Stage Approach to Differentiating Normal and Aberrant Behavior in Computer Based Testing

Permutation tests for detecting and estimating mixtures in task performance within groups.

A screen-time-based mixture model for identifying and monitoring careless and insufficient effort responding in ecological momentary assessment data.

Joint Maximum Likelihood Estimation for High-Dimensional Exploratory Item Factor Analysis