MD-assisted Refinement of X-Ray Coordinates

Oleg Mikhailovskii,Yi Xue,Nikolai R. Skrynnikov
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1107/s0108767319095977
2019-01-01
Acta Crystallographica Section A Foundations and Advances
Abstract:We have developed a software solution to refine crystallographic protein structures using experimental diffraction data in conjunction with state-of-the-art MD modeling setup. For this purpose, a special module to calculate structure factors has been implemented within AMBER16 [1] biomolecular simulations package. The refinement is conducted in a form of a short MD simulation that models the entire unit crystal cell complete with interstitial solvent. The structure-factor-based restraints are imposed in a form of maximum likelihood potential [2], which is balanced against the regular force-field potential. To evaluate the performance of the new refinement protocol, we tested it on a set of 84 protein structures. As a first step, we conducted the refinement of relatively poor initial structural models (average deviation from the target 0.75 Å). It has been found that in 83% of the cases our protocol outperformed the refinement procedures available in Phenix [3] as judged by the lower resultant R free factors. Furthermore, our protocol consistently led to better geometries, as indicated by superior MolProbity scores [4]. As a second step, we refined the coordinates that are deposited in the PDB databank. We found that in 38% of the cases our protocol achieved improvements over both the original PDB depositions and the re-refined variants thereof obtained by Phenix. Of note, the results from Phenix equipped with the advanced Amber ff14SB force field [5] have also been included in this comparison. The approach to structure refinement demonstrated in our work has a number of broad advantages. It explicitly models protein-protein interactions in the crystal, as well as protein-water interactions. It also offers a natural way to represent the protein conformational dynamics: multiple protein molecules in the simulated crystal cell (or block of
What problem does this paper attempt to address?