Abstract:Perceptual learning becomes completely transferrable with double training when the observers receive additional exposure of the transfer stimulus via an irrelevant task. However, we noticed that Vernier learning transferred to a new location after double training only when the training and transfer stimuli shared the same orientation. A second exposure to a suprathreshold orthogonal Vernier was necessary to enable cross-orientation learning transfer (Wang_et_al._2012). Here we investigated whether orientation learning transfer between orthogonal gratings and symmetric dot patterns also requires such triple training (training plus double exposures). Observers learned orientation discrimination of a grating or symmetric dot pattern, and the learning transfer to the other, orthogonal, stimulus was tested. We found (1) Baseline: Grating orientation learning (35°/125°) had little effect on orthogonal dot-pattern orientation discrimination; (2) Double training: Additional exposure to the orthogonal dot patterns via a brightness discrimination task produced incomplete learning transfer to orthogonal dot patterns, since further dot-pattern orientation training induced extra performance gain; (3) Triple training: Observers received exposure of both new orientation and new stimulus via two separate tasks: grating brightness discrimination at the orthogonal orientation, and dot pattern brightness discrimination at the same or orthogonal orientation. After triple training, dot-pattern orthogonal orientation discrimination was improved, and continued training produced no further gains, indicating complete transfer of grating orientation learning to the orthogonal symmetric dot patterns. (4) Control: The above double exposures by themselves had little impact on dot-pattern orientation discrimination. (5) The same patterns of learning transfer results were replicated from dot-patterns to gratings. These results suggest that the brain performs two remapping to transfer perceptual learning. One remaps learning to an orthogonal orientation of the same stimulus, which is enabled by exposure of the same but orthogonal-oriented stimulus. The other remaps learning to a physically distinct stimulus by exposure of the new stimulus.

A new format of perceptual learning based on evidence abstraction from multiple stimuli

Evidence for Stimulus Abstraction Before Perceptual Learning

Perceptual learning evidence for supramodal representation of stimulus orientation at a conceptual level.

Under-stimulation at Untrained Orientation May Explain Orientation Specificity in Perceptual Learning

Perceptual learning with minimal V1 plasticity

Orientation Discrimination and Learning May Not Rely on Direct Sensory Inputs from Orientation Detectors

Many Roads Lead to Rome: Differential Learning Processes for the Same Perceptual Improvement.

Enabling Complete Transfer of Perceptual Learning Across Orientations in Foveal Vision Through Double Training

Feature Variability Determines Specificity and Transfer in Multiorientation Feature Detection Learning

Teaching Visual Orientation Discrimination Through Tactile Learning

The Transfer of Perceptual Learning to a Physically and Orientation Different Stimulus Requires Triple Training

Rule-based Learning Explains Visual Perceptual Learning and Its Specificity and Transfer.

Perceptual Learning at a Conceptual Level

Perceptual Learning in Peripheral Vision with Attention Reflects (mostly) Template Retuning

An Event-Related Potential Study on Perceptual Learning in Grating Orientation Discrimination

Perceptual learning to reduce sensory eye dominance beyond the focus of top-down visual attention

Unconscious Orientation Exposure in TPE Training Enables Transfer of Foveal Orientation Learning to Orthogonal Orientations

Orientation Specificity and Generalization of Perceptual Learning in N-Afc Spatial Frequency Identification.

Vernier Perceptual Learning Transfers to Completely Untrained Retinal Locations after Double Training: A "piggybacking'' Effect

Bottom-Up And Top-Down Influences At Untrained Conditions Determine Perceptual Learning Specificity And Transfer

Complete Transfer of Perceptual Learning Across Retinal Locations Enabled by Double Training