Multi-start Heuristic Approaches for One-to-one Pickup and Delivery Problems with Shortest-Path Transport along Real-Life Paths

Jian Xiong,Xin Qi,Zhuo Fu,Weixiong Zha

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0227702

IF: 3.9

2020-01-01

IEEE Access

Abstract:A variation of the One-to-one Pickup and Delivery Problem (OPDP) in connected graphs, the Split Demand One-to-one Pickup and Delivery Problem with the Shortest-path Transport along Real-life Paths (SDOPDPSTRP) is abstracted from passenger train operation plans based on networks. Unlike the classical OPDP, in the SDOPDPSTRP: the demands can be split and must be transported along the shortest path according to passengers requirements and vehicles should travel along a real-life path. A new kind of integer programming model is formulated for the SDOPDPSTRP based on the connection relationship between pickup-delivery demands (pd-pairs). Two different categories of splitting strategies are proposed to solve the SDOPDPSTRP: split the demands before the calculation and split the demands during the calculation. Two Multi-Start Variable Neighborhood Descent (a MS_VND originating from the other literature and a new MS_VND' IN developed in this article) and seven neighborhood operators are proposed for these two splitting strategies to solve the SDOPDPSTRP. The results show that Approach III outperforms Approach I and Approach II in terms of average solutions with the same algorithm termination conditions and in terms of time efficiency, which has great practical significance for real-life transport organizations.