Abstract:In the field of environmental science and engineering, quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) means the quantitative relationship between the structure of molecules (or their aggregates e.g.. nanoparticles) and certain endpoints. Herein, endpoints generally refer to physicochemical properties. biological effects or environmental behavior parameters, etc. that can be measured or modeled. Based on data sets of chemical structures and their known endpoint values (i.e., training set), QSAR models could, by means of specific algorithms, establish the mathematical relationships between the digital features that characterize the molecular structure (i.e.. descriptors) and the endpoint values. Then, the established mathematical relationships can be employed to predict the endpoint values for given chemical structures. QSAR models are important tools for filling the data gap in environmental safety of chemicals and addressing the issues from so-called "emerging pollutants" that are closely related to the improper management of chemicals. Notably. QSAR models are intrinsically data-driven models. The relationships presented in the training set are not necessarily applicable to arbitrary chemical structures. The reliability of QSAR models is always limited to certain applicability domains. Therefore, acceptance of QSAR models in sound management of chemicals requires clearly defined applicability domains. This study reviewed three concepts of the applicability domain: Descriptor domain, structural domain and mechanism domain. For characterizing descriptor domain, methods based on hyper-rectangle, convex hull, joint probability density estimation and various types of distances were described. Notably, when Boolean fingerprints are used as descriptors, these methods become meaningless. Thus. implementation_ characters and advantages of the structural domain based on fingerprints and similarity, were specially introduced. Moreover, structure-activity landscapes (SALs), as exemplified by a network-like similarity graph (NSG) and a 3D topography of the endpoint and the descriptor values, were also demonstrated. "Activity cliffs" manifested in the SALs were highlighted. Based on the NSG, local discontinuity score (LDS) was calculated to quantitatively describe the "smoothness" of the SAL. LDS was also demonstrated to be linearly correlated to the cross-validation log loss of random forest classifiers for 59 Tox21 bioassay endpoints, further implying that smoothness of the training SAL could be an indicator of the performance of the established QSAR models. The causes of the "activity cliff" were further discussed and assumed to be dependent on the complexity and spatial heterogeneity of the investigated endpoint systems. Particularly, the chaos and emergence behavior of complex systems could be sensitive to tiny but specific structural changes in the small molecules and thus cannot be satisfactorily predicted based purely on the molecular descriptors. Hence. the understanding of the mechanisms underlying the endpoints was emphasized, which corresponds to the concept of the mechanism domain. In conclusion, in order to understand the feasibility of the molecular descriptors, explain the mechanisms of the QSARs. and reasonably select defining methods for the applicability domain, it is essential to address three questions: (1) What system does the endpoint intrinsically describe? (2) How complex and spatially heterogeneous is the system? (3) Whether the endpoint considers the emergence of systems behavior? With the enhancement of chemicals management and the emphasis on the treatment of novel pollutants, the development and use of QSAR models are anticipated to be increased. Only with basic knowledge of the mechanisms underlying the modeled endpoints, with sufficient recognition of the characters of the established QSAR models, and with properly selected applicability domain characterization methods. could the QSAR models yield relatively reliable predictions and thus benefit the environmental management of chemicals in China.

Applicability Domains Enhance Application of PPARγ Agonist Classifiers Trained by Drug-like Compounds to Environmental Chemicals.

Developing QSAR Models with Defined Applicability Domains on PPARγ Binding Affinity Using Large Data Sets and Machine Learning Algorithms.

Predicting the Androgenicity of Structurally Diverse Compounds from Molecular Structure Using Different Classifiers

Molecular Docking, Molecular Dynamics Simulation, and Structure-Based 3D-QSAR Studies on the Aryl Hydrocarbon Receptor Agonistic Activity of Hydroxylated Polychlorinated Biphenyls.

Predictive Models for Identifying the Binding Activity of Structurally Diverse Chemicals to Human Pregnane X Receptor.

Virtual Screening of Potentially Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals Against Nuclear Receptors and Its Application to Identify PPARγ-bound Fatty Acids

Characterization of Applicability Domains for QSAR Models

Virtual identification of novel peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR) α/δ dual antagonist by 3D-QSAR, molecule docking and molecule dynamics simulation.

Assessment of Prediction Confidence and Domain Extrapolation of Two Structure-Activity Relationship Models for Predicting Estrogen Receptor Binding Activity

Interpretable machine learning for the identification of estrogen receptor agonists, antagonists, and binders

Qsar Prediction of Estrogen Activity for A Large Set of Diverse Chemicals under the Guidance of Oecd Principles

Uncovering PPAR-γ agonists: An integrated computational approach driven by machine learning

Improvement in the screening performance of potential aryl hydrocarbon receptor ligands by using supervised machine learning

Development of a Robust Read-Across Model for the Prediction of Biological Potency of Novel Peroxisome Proliferator-Activated Receptor Delta Agonists

Classification of bioaccumulative and non-bioaccumulative chemicals using statistical learning approaches

SepPCNET: Deeping Learning on a 3D Surface Electrostatic Potential Point Cloud for Enhanced Toxicity Classification and Its Application to Suspected Environmental Estrogens

ED Profiler: Machine Learning Tool for Screening Potential Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals

In Silico Predication of Nuclear Hormone Receptors for Organic Pollutants by Homology Modeling and Molecular Docking

Initial Development of Automated Machine Learning-Assisted Prediction Tools for Aryl Hydrocarbon Receptor Activators

Absorption, Distribution, Metabolism, Excretion, and Toxicity Evaluation in Drug Discovery. 14. Prediction of Human Pregnane X Receptor Activators by Using Naive Bayesian Classification Technique.

Computational Models to Predict Endocrine-Disrupting Chemical Binding with Androgen or Oestrogen Receptors.